Abby’s Guide > Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) > Discussions > Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe? (Morphed into Platinum vs Deluxe)
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions |
|
Snowmann
Joined: Dec 3, 2003
Points: 494
|
|
Re: Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe?
Reply #4 Sep 24, 2010 12:06 pm |
|
Snowmann, I realize that on the Compact series I lose the ATC, but I was under the impression that the 920015 DID come with a Quick-Turn Chute and remote Deflector. Not true? Hopefully the Ariens mechanism is more robust than some of the other joystick chutes that have reported problems. If I elect to go that way (920015) to save a few $$$ would the 26" width and 249cc Briggs still do well on the EOD? The "Quick Turn" feature on the Platinums and Pros is a single lever with ~80 degrees or so of travel that will turn the chute 200 degrees. It has a feature whereas the chute automatically locks and unlocks when the control is used. It is very fast, but it requires reasonably accurate adjustment to work correctly (expertise that you might not get during setup at a mass retailer). It's simple to adjust (detailed in the owners manual).
The Deluxe,Compact, and Sno-Tek models use a "2.5X Quick Turn" which is a crank mechanism that turns the chute 200 degrees (205 degrees on Compacts) with only 2.5 Turns of a crank. The "Ice Drill" variant of this is the same only that the handle is inline with the crank instead of at the end (like a manual ice drill). The chute is held in place during operation by friction materials under compression in the pivot axis. As this feature is much simpler in design, it has the potential to be less problematic than more complex systems (requires little or no adjustment, fewer moving parts). The 26" Compact model with the 249cc Briggs has power to spare for any condition and will be more than enough for the EOD. This same engine is used on the larger 14" impeller (Deluxe) models whereas the power consumption and capacity can be much higher. That said, it's has plenty of reserve power for this model. The 26" Compact also does have a remote cap deflector. PK
|
amazer98
Joined: Dec 7, 2009
Points: 46
|
|
Re: Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe?
Reply #5 Sep 28, 2010 5:19 pm |
|
Last year I initially bought the Deluxe 24 and later exchanged it for the Platinum version. The biggest benefit to me and the reason I upgraded was that the traction control made the Platinum a helluva lot easier to turn-- you really have to horse the Deluxe around when it's time to change direction. That gets old very quickly! The bigger Deluxe models have triggers that remotely release locking pins on the axle, which makes them easier to turn than the Deluxe 24. I suppose Ariens thought the 24" model was light enough to simply push and twist around to do a 180, but I found it to be a real pain in the a$$. The Platinum 24 also has a headlight, which comes in handy at my EOD where the driveway illumination peters out (no streetlights here in Hollis, NH!). The upgraded controls for changing chute direction a half-second faster and for remotely controlling the deflector did not seem to be major advantages, and I could certainly happily live without them. Similarly, the handwarmers are a nice touch, but not a necessity. If I had to choose, I guess I'd pick the handwarmers over the chute control upgrade. By the way, I found the Briggs engine to be great-- it starts very easily (no need for the electric assist, but it's there if you need it) and ran smoothly and powerfully, which was a pleasant surprise. I am very happy with the Ariens quality, especially at its price-point compared to Toro and Honda. It's a well balanced, solidly built machine. NOTE: I just went to Ariens' website and this year they no longer are producing the Deluxe 24-- only the Deluxe 28 and 30. If you want a 24" model, your choices are the Compact 24 or the Platinum 24. To my mind this makes sense-- the Compact with its smaller engine would obviously be easier to turn around than the old Deluxe 24, and the Platinum 24 has a bigger engine plus all the bells and whistles. I'd say that if you typically do not get more than two storms a season that exceed 8 or 10 inches, go for the Compact. If you get a lot more snow than that at a time, go for the Platinum.
This message was modified Sep 28, 2010 by amazer98
|
amazer98
Joined: Dec 7, 2009
Points: 46
|
|
Re: Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe?
Reply #7 Sep 29, 2010 11:28 am |
|
I would just add that it's easy to underestimate how fast you can do a driveway with one of these things. For example, our driveway is about 70 feet long, plus in the area adjacent to our two-car garage there is a parking area about 30x30 feet.
I got the Platinum 24 instead of a larger machine because I need to park it in front of my car and there's not a lot of extra room there. I figured it would take me a bit longer to do the driveway, but I just didn't want to try a squeeze a wider machine in that tight a space.
Well, it turned out that even with a 9 inch storm (about the biggest we got here last year), it took only 30 minutes to clean the entire driveway. I was surprised at how quickly the 24" unit made quick work of the snow, throwing it across the drive like a cannon. The 249cc B&S engine worked great, as I wrote above. I would say that unless perhaps you were using the machine commercially, going for a more expensive Subie engine would be a waste of $$$.
It strikes me that going for a bigger unit or pricier engine for a relatively modest sized driveway is akin to buying Hummer because you need to negotiate a gravel driveway.
|
mmiguy
Joined: Sep 15, 2010
Points: 11
|
|
Re: Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe?
Reply #9 Sep 29, 2010 2:14 pm |
|
If you are paying more than $1299 for the 24 platinum, you are paying too much. Home depot has it for 1299 with free shipping. They shipped mine to the local Ariens dealer for setup. I bought a set if slides and shear pins and everyone was happy.
|
amazer98
Joined: Dec 7, 2009
Points: 46
|
|
Re: Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe?
Reply #11 Sep 29, 2010 3:24 pm |
|
amazer you are correct...I'm sure the 30"er is more than I need but the Deluxe 30 with the Subaru is actually less $$$ than the 24" Platinum. I guess you are saying that the remote chute and Auto traction are worth more than the Subaru engine and the wider machine? I didn't realize that the D30 w/ Subie was actually less than the Platinum 24. That makes the decision an interesting one. Personally, I'd go for the P24 because: - I'm not convinced that the Subie engine is that much better than the B&S. Perhaps it is, but I'm totally happy with the easy starting and power of the B&S
- The ATC makes the P24 very easy to turn-- you never have to stop the unit, press the trigger, turn it around and get it to re-engage every time you change direction
- The handwarmers are definitely nice on the Platinum series
- While the Platinum's quick chute reverser and remote deflector control are not a must-have, they are nice features.
- A 30" wide unit will go through snow quicker in general, but once you get to a storm more than 8 or 9 inches, you'll have to slow down the speed or you'll overstuff the chute. Don't forget, the chute is the same whether you have a 24" or 34" model, and it can handle only so many cubic inches of snow a second. Given the size of your drive, you probably won't save more than a few minutes using a 30".
Anyway, these are just my $.02. I don't think you can make a real mistake with either unit, but I know you'd be happy with the Platinum 24.
This message was modified Sep 29, 2010 by amazer98
|
slinger
Joined: Sep 22, 2010
Points: 158
|
|
Re: Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe?
Reply #12 Sep 29, 2010 4:17 pm |
|
Thanks to all for your input. I know the Deluxe 30" w/Subaru is a great deal. I would love to have that engine on a Platinum 24...now THAT would be one helluva machine! Yes, I am aware of the pricing at HD & Snow Blowers Direct. At HD I'd have to pay tax which makes a $1299 Platinum 24 $1390 delivered (free). Snow Blowers Direct has free shipping as well and no tax but their price is $1399, so it's a wash. I asked them (SBD) if they would have this sale price like HD has. Snow Blowers Direct's reply: That would depend on Ariens. They went ahead and fulfilled all of Home Depot’s order and then didn’t have any left over for anyone else. So the sale they were running through the month of September does not apply for us since we won’t get any of these units in until October. There sale is all rebate incentive, so we need a serial number to get the money. We are hoping they will extend it, but we may have gotten the short end of the stick.
|
DavidNJ
Joined: Sep 26, 2010
Points: 206
|
|
Re: Ariens decision question: Compact series or Deluxe?
Reply #13 Sep 29, 2010 11:50 pm |
|
A couple of things.
First, price. It always nice to save money, but there is a point of no return. A trip to Home Depot with a pickup can cost $6-10 depending how close it is. Having it assembled and inspected by a dealer familar with the brand has some advantages also. Annual maintenance will cost a few dollars, the unit will last 10-25 years. $100 more or less isn't the end of the earth.
Second, I have another thread on the auto traction control, but a couple of things. One, no steering is a big loser. There are dozens of complaints about having to muscle it around and revelations when they later bought a unit with steering. Some sort of left right differential ability is nearly essential IMHO. But which. Some are labeled 'power steering'. These have left and right releases that diengage the left and right wheel, respectively. Others, usually only on larger units, are only for either the left wheel or the right wheel. These, such as the one on the Ariens, can be a toggling mechanism that disengages or engages and doesn't have to be held. They work like a power steering system when the disengaged wheel is on the inside of the turn. When it is on the outside of the turn it probably will have to apply a little elbow grease. There is one response on my auto traction control thread. The auto traction control is in overrunning clutch that lets a wheel move faster than the transmission but not slower. That would make it like having a single wheel release where you always returning with the disengaged wheel on the outside. The one response so far indicates what you would expect: it still takes a bit of muscle to move it around.
Third, width is a very interesting thing. Too little and the job will seemed to take forever. Too much and you may find there are areas that are difficult to maneuver the snowblower into. And there's another problem often found in the automotive world: the best features are only on the biggest models. If you want the nicest interior you can't get it on a BMW 3 Series or Mercedes C class. Even if you want a smaller car than a 7 Series or an S class.
Fourth, there are differences in motors but the whole market is very convoluted. I kind of like what I've heard about the overhead cam SX Subarus. However, unless you are most of these units back to back you would never know the difference. What may be more important is to find out who would be doing service on the unit and asked that dealer what he thinks of the different brands. I imagine all will be fine with Briggs & Stratton and Subaru and would have been fine with Tecumseh if it still existed. They may or may not have issues with the other Chinese brands.
Fifth, some cranks are very fast, less than the returns lock to lock. Some are very slow, 10 to 20 turns lock to lock. You absolutely don't want a slow one. The various joystick handles are probably just as okay as a fast crank, but a slow one is a nightmare. That I know from experience.
Now that I blabbed for a few paragraphs let me state that I find the whole thing very confusing and haven't been able to make a clear selection myself let alone be able to recommend specific unit in a different size or price range..
|
|
|