Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions

Are these any better than a snow shovel ??

 

[URL=http://img242.imageshack.us/my.php?image=0603720450cc4db8d5ey.jpg][IMG]http://img242.imageshack.us/img242/489/0603720450cc4db8d5ey.th.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

 

This one is an MTD Yardmachine from Canadian Tire. It has 5 hp, with a 21” cut.

It retails for $499.99 Cdn., with a 2-year warranty.

 

[URL=http://img242.imageshack.us/my.php?image=75b5695e3b3549188a151a3b2016f4.jpg][IMG]http://img242.imageshack.us/img242/3562/75b5695e3b3549188a151a3b2016f4.th.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

 

This one is a Murray from Home Depot. It also has 5 hp, with a 21” cut. It retails

for $477 Cdn. and also has a 2-year warranty.

 

WalMart has a Murray, 4.5 hp, with a 21” cut that retails for $537 Cdn. but is marked down to $457 (sorry, no picture – but it is yellow !!)

 

I think all 3 have the Techumsch engine.

 

So, why am I asking this question and for your advice ??

 

I have a 2 stage, 10.5 hp with a 30” cut and it is has the left/right controls for steering.

 

I have used a 2 stage for the past 30+ years and have never used a single stage.

 

There are times when there’s more snow than I feel like shovelling but not enough to justify taking out the 2 stage. Hate to admit it, but I’m getting a tad older (now retired) and my back often complains when I shovel too much.

 

Was thinking about getting me one of the above to help the situation – they seem pretty light and easy to manoeuvre. I would do the driveway and walkways and some EOD stuff, if it wasn’t too much or too heavy.

 

But, even at the quoted prices, it’s an expensive shovel !!

 

Do you think it’s worth the investment ? And, if so, is one of the above any better than the other ??

 

Thanks for any assistance that you might provide.

 

Cheers = Roger

Are these any better than a snow shovel ??

 

 

This one is an MTD Yardmachine from Canadian Tire. It has 5 hp, with a 21” cut.

It retails for $499.99 Cdn., with a 2-year warranty.

 

 

This one is a Murray from Home Depot. It also has 5 hp, with a 21” cut. It retails

for $477 Cdn. and also has a 2-year warranty.

 

WalMart has a Murray, 4.5 hp, with a 21” cut that retails for $537 Cdn. but is marked down to $457 (sorry, no picture – but it is yellow !!)

 

I think all 3 have the Techumsch engine.

 

So, why am I asking this question and for your advice ??

 

I have a 2 stage, 10.5 hp with a 30” cut and it is has the left/right controls for steering.

 

I have used a 2 stage for the past 30+ years and have never used a single stage.

 

There are times when there’s more snow than I feel like shovelling but not enough to justify taking out the 2 stage. Hate to admit it, but I’m getting a tad older (now retired) and my back often complains when I shovel too much.

 

Was thinking about getting me one of the above to help the situation – they seem pretty light and easy to manoeuvre. I would do the driveway and walkways and some EOD stuff, if it wasn’t too much or too heavy.

 

But, even at the quoted prices, it’s an expensive shovel !!

 

Do you think it’s worth the investment ? And, if so, is one of the above any better than the other ??

 

Thanks for any assistance that you might provide.

 

Cheers = Roger

To answer your question.... They both $uck...
If you have been using a 2 stage machine, you will not be happy with either of these.
if the snow is to small for a 2 stage, your better off with a shovel.
Just my 2 cents but its your buck.

Thanks for the pics. 70 chevrolet

i disagree w/ 70 chevy. i have an old paddle wheel jacobsen snowburst.  if the snow is only 2 or 3 inches,(maybe 4) i alwyas grab it instead of the 2 stage beheamouth. the rubber padlees get
closer to the pavement.Its so light that I can toss it around as necessary.

Just the rt tool for the job If its over 5 inches, though, its thetwo stage.

the shovel is for the steps only

Thanks to you both for your comments.

That makes 1 vote for and 1 vote against......

Anybody else got an opinion ??

For what it matters. 

If I had to pick between running a two stage snowblower and a "snow-shovel"  I would always go for the two stage.  Maybe I just want to throw that snow farther, maybe it is the loud noise and killer power that I love.  Let the snow shovel stay inside and play barbie doll while we take care of business in the driveway.

For what it matters.....

NFLD,

I f you buy a single stage, buy the Toro.

Much better made equipment!!!!

IMHO

                                               Fred

solara wrote:

There is no comparison between the Jacobson and the Murray or MTD machines. The Murray and the MTD are JUNK!!!!!  Get a Toro or an Ariens single stage, you can't beat the quality of either machine.

To DNK1....

Careful...one man's meat is another man's poison!!!!  Some people wouldn't buy a Ford on a bet.... and others swear that Ford is the ONLY vehicle they would buy!!!  So to characterize another person's possible choice as JUNK suggests that unless your opinions are embraced as gospel, their decision would be s$%@ might be a little over the top!!!  A reasoned comparison would be more helpful in decision-making.

*(:>)*

In the one "big" (8 inches) storm we had this year(we arent going to have any more because we bought a snow blower, (maybe it will dubble as a rototiller?) My neighbor took out his brand new 5ish HP two stage machine. It was so awsome, he woulg go, for like 2 feet, sure it would take 20-30 seconds, but then...It would stall out and die. and he would have to restart it... He eventually mastered it and wow, after 10 minutes he had cleared a whopping 20 foot 18 inch wide section of walk. I used that to convince my mom to by something a little heftier.

So, unless you live in california, or you have 500 extra dollars for when those flurries come around, steer clear, or invest in salt.