Vacuum Cleaners Discussions |
|
Venson
Joined: Jul 23, 2007
Points: 1900
|
|
Re: Vacuum bags and filters and their impact on the environment?
Reply #5 Apr 27, 2010 2:12 pm |
|
Generally Miele's high filtration synthetic dust bags aren't re-useable and unless you buy an old Miele off EBAY with 1400 watts you can buy the cheaper brown paper bags. The cheaper paper bags however will burst in current Miele models as they are not used to the general higher suction motors.
Hi vacmanuk,
I think they are re-re-usable but the argument for not opening and then attempting to re-seal them is the possible damage to your vacuum if the job's not done well. Nonetheless, disposable vacuum bags are a small worry as far as the enviroment is concerned -- biodegradable or not.. If rest of the inhabitants of our planet were to follow the American model regarding consumption we'd need about five more Earths to hold all the junk. Venson
|
Just
Joined: Nov 28, 2007
Points: 172
|
|
Re: Vacuum bags and filters and their impact on the environment?
Reply #7 Apr 28, 2010 11:02 am |
|
One could always buy an older "Vintage" Kirby or Hoover with a shake out bag. You would not only be reusing, but no bags in the wastestream. In actuality I think that bags are mostly made of paper or cellulose which are biodegradable, and the contents are . . . Well. . . DIRT. In my opinion there are far worse things harming our environment than cellulose and dirt.
This message was modified Apr 28, 2010 by Just
|
Hertz
Joined: Jan 31, 2010
Points: 199
|
|
Re: Vacuum bags and filters and their impact on the environment?
Reply #8 Apr 28, 2010 8:35 pm |
|
One could always buy an older "Vintage" Kirby or Hoover with a shake out bag. You would not only be reusing, but no bags in the wastestream. In actuality I think that bags are mostly made of paper or cellulose which are biodegradable, and the contents are . . . Well. . . DIRT. In my opinion there are far worse things harming our environment than cellulose and dirt. Again, PAPER bags are FINE! Heck, even just the cloth on the Miele would be fine, but it's that EXCESSIVE amount of plastic they use for the closing flap w/ metal on it. It's not even just the environment but it's WASTEFUL! I mean, with all the bags thrown out w/ that much plastic, you could probably make a 100 Miele bodies! At least, if it's the same plastic ;) Still though, I guess because Miele's are so damn well built and that they last forever and not gunk up the environment with HUGE amounts of plastic like cheap China-crap I guess the "burden" is VASTLY alleviated, but still, I just wish Miele would use cardboard for closing their bags instead of so much unnecessary plastic. Ugh.
|
"There is no BEST or PERFECT vacuum cleaner"
"Take care of your vacuum, then your vacuum will take care of you"
Joined: Dec 1, 2004
Points: 1683
|
|
Re: Vacuum bags and filters and their impact on the environment?
Reply #11 Apr 29, 2010 2:12 pm |
|
Hi vacmanuk, I think they are re-re-usable but the argument for not opening and then attempting to re-seal them is the possible damage to your vacuum if the job's not done well.
Venson Whatever anyone does, do not reuse disposable vacuum cleaner bags. While some may think that bag makers want you to purchase their bags, for their sake, it is not true. When the bag fills, fine dust will embed in the pores of the bags. There will be a point, when the bag will clog. So when you remove the dirt, there is still going to be dirt in the pores. Knowing the habits of many vacuum cleaner owners, I cannot see them knowing when to change the bag after they have reused it. They will think it does not need to be changed, because they do not see any dirt in the bag. They do not hear the change in the motor as it struggles to move air. HOOVER did have the Handisac, that could be reused a few times. If your bag package says to not reuse, which they all do, do not reuse. Paper bags were created to make dirt removal, from the vacuum cleaner easier and cleaner. If you do not want to pay the price for some vacuum cleaner bags, there are vacuum cleaners that do not have expensive upkeep. So remember what I said, Do not reuse disposable vacuum cleaner bags.
This message was modified Apr 29, 2010 by Mike_W
|
vacmanuk
Location: Scotland UK
Joined: May 31, 2009
Points: 1162
|
|
Re: Vacuum bags and filters and their impact on the environment?
Reply #12 Apr 29, 2010 3:17 pm |
|
Again, PAPER bags are FINE! Heck, even just the cloth on the Miele would be fine, but it's that EXCESSIVE amount of plastic they use for the closing flap w/ metal on it. It's not even just the environment but it's WASTEFUL! I mean, with all the bags thrown out w/ that much plastic, you could probably make a 100 Miele bodies! At least, if it's the same plastic ;) Still though, I guess because Miele's are so damn well built and that they last forever and not gunk up the environment with HUGE amounts of plastic like cheap China-crap I guess the "burden" is VASTLY alleviated, but still, I just wish Miele would use cardboard for closing their bags instead of so much unnecessary plastic. Ugh. Hertz - sorry to disagree with you, but Do you know anything about Miele? Do you know that they recycle the plastic from old machines to make components such as the grid flaps? Sebo also do the same. How environmentally recycleable friendly do you want? The Intensive Clean bags have a lot more plastic going on, including the pull/corrugated strip to close the dust channel on the bag. Miele have done well here with their later bags in minimising plastic. I find the cheaper paper pleated HEPA cartridge filter blocks fitted to many Electrolux products as wasteful - the grids can't be removed because they are bonded and the paper pleats therefore can't be burnt off. The reason to why there is a plastic grid is down to the suction of the modern motor. The 1200 watts and 1400 watt older Miele models that use the brown paper bags have cardboard holders. Put that bag into a 1600 watt Miele model that has improved seals and you'll find the bag will burst and also come off the cardboard collar. Cardboard collars can only be applied to vacuums that have lower rated powered motors. Sebo bags for their high powered C and K series also have plastic grid holders bonded onto the paper.
This message was modified Apr 29, 2010 by vacmanuk
|
Hertz
Joined: Jan 31, 2010
Points: 199
|
|
Re: Vacuum bags and filters and their impact on the environment?
Reply #13 Apr 29, 2010 5:50 pm |
|
Hertz - sorry to disagree with you, but Do you know anything about Miele? Do you know that they recycle the plastic from old machines to make components such as the grid flaps? Sebo also do the same. How environmentally recycleable friendly do you want? The Intensive Clean bags have a lot more plastic going on, including the pull/corrugated strip to close the dust channel on the bag. Miele have done well here with their later bags in minimising plastic.
I find the cheaper paper pleated HEPA cartridge filter blocks fitted to many Electrolux products as wasteful - the grids can't be removed because they are bonded and the paper pleats therefore can't be burnt off. The reason to why there is a plastic grid is down to the suction of the modern motor. The 1200 watts and 1400 watt older Miele models that use the brown paper bags have cardboard holders. Put that bag into a 1600 watt Miele model that has improved seals and you'll find the bag will burst and also come off the cardboard collar. Cardboard collars can only be applied to vacuums that have lower rated powered motors. Sebo bags for their high powered C and K series also have plastic grid holders bonded onto the paper. Yes, I do know quite a bit about Miele, considering I did a 6 page powerpoint on them for school in German class, but I did not know that. That's pretty incredible, and really makes a difference. Very cool. Where do you find this stuff out, by the way? Finally; That's BULL CRAP about the cardboard collars not being able to handle the higher suction; *MORE* powerful vacuums in Europe such as Sweden Lux's use cardboard collared bags which hold up just fine, and these machines have crazy 2200W motors in them. No, the only reason Miele uses plastic would be for improved rigidity, though completely unnecessary.
|
Venson
Joined: Jul 23, 2007
Points: 1900
|
|
Re: Vacuum bags and filters and their impact on the environment?
Reply #14 Apr 29, 2010 7:23 pm |
|
Whatever anyone does, do not reuse disposable vacuum cleaner bags. While some may think that bag makers want you to purchase their bags, for their sake, it is not true. When the bag fills, fine dust will embed in the pores of the bags. There will be a point, when the bag will clog. So when you remove the dirt, there is still going to be dirt in the pores. Knowing the habits of many vacuum cleaner owners, I cannot see them knowing when to change the bag after they have reused it. They will think it does not need to be changed, because they do not see any dirt in the bag. They do not hear the change in the motor as it struggles to move air.
HOOVER did have the Handisac, that could be reused a few times. If your bag package says to not reuse, which they all do, do not reuse. Paper bags were created to make dirt removal, from the vacuum cleaner easier and cleaner.
If you do not want to pay the price for some vacuum cleaner bags, there are vacuum cleaners that do not have expensive upkeep.
So remember what I said, Do not reuse disposable vacuum cleaner bags.
Mike, I'm glad you issued the warning but there will always be some people who'll try to defy the laws of physics. I had a relative whom, no matter how you tried to persuade her that re-using disposable vac bags was not a good practice, always gave in to her sense of thrift. She did in an Electrolux and a Filter Queen I'd gifted her and several other machines she bought herself.
A lot of people do not have a sensitivity to vac motor sounds I think. For them the time to change the bag is when their machine absolutely won't pick anything up. Never good. Venson
|
|
|