Model2, Samsung has many many many multi-cyclonic's that have not been challenged by Dyson (demonstrating Dyson does not enjoy taking people to court as some say here). Samsung has a patent/s on sequential separation. Dyson Core + Root combination pre-date Samsung’s. If you look in the European patent office you'll see Samsung's sequential separators or large separators then downstream are smaller separators.- I'm 95% sure this is the infringing patent.
On second thought, maybe the infringement is over the dual cyclone. Who knows.
Moose, Thanks for the article. It is good to see Sir James find another superior innovation that’s insured and fortified by a strong patent. Sequential separators should out perform I'll previous separators. Not to mention what a great use of space the Core + Root were made to fit.
DIB
P.S. It is nice to see the little guy take on another monster sized corporation. It's equally nice to see Sir James again (as he always does) praise his people vice taking credit all to himself.
This message was modified Jan 22, 2009 by DysonInventsBig
Dyson dumb. Bit off his nose to spite his face [read: ego]. After the US, Japan is probably dyson's most lucrative market. Spin this story anyway you want, but the bottom line is this: No other consumer market is more loyal to its heritage than the Japanese. Dyson just lost the Japanese market. Mark my words.
Dyson dumb. Bit off his nose to spite his face [read: ego]. After the US, Japan is probably dyson's most lucrative market. Spin this story anyway you want, but the bottom line is this: No other consumer market is more loyal to its heritage than the Japanese. Dyson just lost the Japanese market. Mark my words.
Carmine D.
Hello Carmine,
You're entitled to your opinion, as always, but I disagree with you on this point.
No one was more surprised than Dyson that they have become established in the Japanese market in the face of strong domestic competition, in such a short time. Their product's small size, high technology and attention to detail have made them a top seller. In their marketing they proudly state their vacs are 'Designed in the UK' - presumably because the fact that it's foreign product appeals to a lot of people buying the machines.
I'm not dismissing the prospect that the Samsung patent case *could* have a negative impact on sales. But clearly, a competitor having a machine which infringes on their patents and in a stroke, removes all the hard work and expense that's gone in to giving it this USP shouldn't be tolerated either.
If this case *was* to get any publicity in Japan, I'd like to think that Japanese people are clear minded enough to see it's a simple business resolution that went to court and happened to be awarded in favour of Dyson.
My prediction: Nothing major will come of this, mark my words.
No product. No threat. No loss. Ego, pure and simple. Dyson's done in Japan. Close shop. Pack up. Go home. The party's over.
If you like and would, please post dyson sales for Japan before the lawsuit. And we'll track here over time to see the impact. If you would?
BTW, fans of dyson and APPLE like to compare the two companies and products in their industries. For example, both have products that are high-end discretionary purchases. James and Jobs as CEO's are singularly identified with their companies. Both are overly protective of their patents, logos etc. Both loathe Wal*Mart stores and speak disparagingly about them and the customers who shop at them. Nevertheless they sacrifice their elitist attitudes, for the sake of profit, and sell their wares in W*M stores. APPLE the leader in its industry is currently valued below its two largest rivals Hewlett-Packard and Dell. Even with Jobs absent, APPLE stock should trade above its two peers and it's not. APPLE has an unbeatable brand name in technology and a diversified product line up [sound familiar]. What has APPLE done most recently: Realizing that its high end products [read: luxury consumer goods] are susceptible and vulnerable to a nasty recession, APPLE has broadened its range to include lower price points. Big box stores already are discounting dysons way below MAP and offering buyer incentives too. How long will dyson take to follow suit [that's follow suit not file suit and no pun intended].
Dyson and you called this one wrong.
Carmine D.
This message was modified Jan 22, 2009 by CarmineD
No product. No threat. No loss. Ego, pure and simple. Dyson's done in Japan. Close shop. Pack up. Go home. The party's over.
If you like and would, please post dyson sales for Japan before the lawsuit. And we'll track here over time to see the impact. If you would?
BTW, fans of dyson and APPLE like to compare the two companies and products in their industries. For example, both have products that are high-end discretionary purchases. James and Jobs as CEO's are singularly identified with their companies. Both are overly protective of their patents, logos etc. Both loathe Wal*Mart stores and speak disparagingly about them and the customers who shop at them. Nevertheless they sacrifice their elitist attitudes, for the sake of profit, and sell their wares in W*M stores. APPLE the leader in its industry is currently valued below its two largest rivals Hewlett-Packard and Dell. Even with Jobs absent, APPLE stock should trade above its two peers and it's not. APPLE has an unbeatable brand name in technology and a diversified product line up [sound familiar]. What has APPLE done most recently: Realizing that its high end products [read: luxury consumer goods] are susceptible and vulnerable to a nasty recession, APPLE has broadened its range to include lower price points. Big box stores already are discounting dysons way below MAP and offering buyer incentives too. How long will dyson take to follow suit [that's follow suit not file suit and no pun intended].
