" My understanding is the grey/brown dry ash chould extend for 1/2 the horizontal section of the shank. That's generally what I see. Your plug has the ash extend way past the curve down the verticle section. That seems to me hot but just how hot and the effect I'm not sure."
Not sure where you get/got your instructions for reading spark plugs but from my experience, you might be "reading" too much into it.
The key to reading the plug is the colour of the area exposed to the combustion process. Tan is the desired colour. How much on each component is of no concern as long as they're all tan.
From the picture I provided, it's pretty clear that it's all tan, which indicates an engine that's running properly. As you are aware, I pretty much specialize in two cycle engines and I have to say that the spark plug in the HSK850 is about as good as it gets. There should be very little variance between a properly running four cycle engine and a properly running two cycle engine. If the fuel to air mixture is correct and the spark plug in the correct heat range, the plug should look similar to the picture of the one I've posted.
I've seen what hot plugs and lean conditions can do to a two stroke engine. I've fixed more than a few snowmobile engines that had holed pistons from too hot of a plug to too lean a fuel mixture. It's not a pretty sight. I'm more than happy with the condition of the plug in the Craftsman. Particularly since it's been pushed for hours with no sign of a problem yet.
You want to see ugly? Check this out. It's the plug from my B&S 305cc Kool Bore snow engine. Can't say for sure if it was the oil but I had been running nothing but Mobile 1 5w30 synthetic in it. I changed to a 5W30 high mileage conventional and after running it for a season, the plug looked better last time I pulled it.
Here's a good link with lots of spark plug reading info:
http://www.theultralightplace.com/sparkplugs.htm
This message was modified Feb 2, 2012 by borat