Abby's Guide to Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more)
Username Password
Discussions Reviews More Guides
Abby’s Guide > Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) > Discussions > Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD

Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions

Search For:
Dr_Woof


Don't blow into the wind, and don't eat yellow snow. WOOF!

Location: Saskatchewan
Joined: Dec 13, 2010
Points: 253

Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Original Message   Jan 20, 2011 12:35 pm
Seen a lot of questions and comments on this so I'll just post my 2 cents worth.  We get a lot of HARD blown in snow around here.  Just bought a Honda HS928TCD (tracks) and I think it's night and day compared to two other wheel types I have used.  Yes, the Honda is (only slightly) harder to make a turn at the end of the line, but this is very much more than compensated for by not having to fight the blower through the first 200 yards of hard snow to get to the turn.  The Honda just pushes ahead and and is very easy to steer.

The hydrostatic drive on the Honda is good to have.  It shifts on the fly (no declutching) to adjust to any speed required do get the job done right.  The electric chute controls are wonderful - don't seem to have a problem freezing up.  When looking to buy, I found the manual chute controls on Hondas sturdily built but a bit hard to turn compared to others.  Electric....good.  WIsh the Honda had heated grips (it's -36 C here today!).

When going through lots of harder snow, the Honda engine is obviously working harder.  I compensate by slowing down forward speed or taking a partial cut - no sense in putting undue stress on the new guy, but I suppose it's only logical that more snow to move equals harder work for the engine.

The two wheelies took a lot of muscle for the hard snow - almost woulda been easier to shovel it.  My old wheelie (JD 826 with chains and "summer" tires) went thru but slowly and with difficulty and lots of muscle required.  The other new wheelie (since returned to dealer), equipped with "snow hog" type tires simply refused to touch the stuff.  I looked into getting chains for the snow hogs, but most dealers, even those that sold chains made expressly for the snow hogs, said they didn't help much (one said they made things worse!).

The Honda tracker is definitely more difficult to handle than a wheelie when in the garage on dry concrete, but I can live with that.  Maybe the suggestion of putting it on a creeper would help, but I just don't have to move it around there much anyway.  Come summer: prep it, store it and see ya next winter.

Bottom line (for me): probably almost anything will go through soft snow, but if you need to blow hard snow, get a tracked model.  I love my HS928TCD , and I imagine the new Yamahas and perhaps other tracked models (ie Ariens, but no hydrostatic drive) would work as well.

Replies: 1 - 10 of 22NextNext page of topicsAllView as Outline
rubinew


Joined: Dec 30, 2010
Points: 147

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #1   Jan 20, 2011 12:58 pm
Great review!

I have had a similar experience with the tracked Yamaha! Yes, a little harder to turn, but a lot less work getting to the point where you need to turn!      

The Yamaha will bog down as well with a full hit of hard snow, have to slow the drive to almost a crawl, which is easy to do with hyrdro static drive.

My old blower didn't bog as much, because I could never feed it packed snow the way I can with the track drive.

I am sure you will get many years of reliable service out of your Honda!

      

Paul7


Joined: Mar 12, 2007
Points: 452

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #2   Jan 20, 2011 1:22 pm
I wonder where the sweet spot ends with tracks and maneuverability.   I mean it sounds like an in-shape 40 year old man would have no problems with tracks.  But would you recommend tracks to someone who's more advanced in years?  So lets say someone in their late fiftys...with the machine built to last 20 to 25 years,  would they still be able to handle it when they're in their seventies?
This message was modified Jan 20, 2011 by Paul7
rubinew


Joined: Dec 30, 2010
Points: 147

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #3   Jan 20, 2011 4:25 pm
I don't remember who posted it, but it was on this forum that I read this tip, and it works well.

When ready to turn, leaned the Auger back, the TCD has a gas lever for that, then lift up lightly on the handles, this tips the weight forward, and spin around, it actually works very well, I did keep a slight bit of forward track movement as well.

So to clarify better:

As I come to the end of a cut I slow the forward motion to a crawl, lean the auger back, lift a little on the handles, shifting the weight to the front of the tracks, then rotate 180,

adjust chute, lean auger back to desired forward position, and keep on blowing!

Dr_Woof


Don't blow into the wind, and don't eat yellow snow. WOOF!

Location: Saskatchewan
Joined: Dec 13, 2010
Points: 253

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #4   Jan 20, 2011 4:59 pm
Paul7 wrote:
I wonder where the sweet spot ends with tracks and maneuverability.   I mean it sounds like an in-shape 40 year old man would have no problems with tracks.  But would you recommend tracks to someone who's more advanced in years?  So lets say someone in their late fiftys...with the machine built to last 20 to 25 years,  would they still be able to handle it when they're in their seventies?

Well....I'm 67,  had shoulder surgery (BEFORE I got the Honda  lol) a few months ago, so I hope so.  I find the Honda easier to handle in hard or soft snow than the wheelies.  Little harder on the turns, not much and just take it easy.  Blower I tried earlier with "Easy Steer" required constant muscling  to keep it going in a straight line in soft snow especially when taking a partial cut which produced an asymmetric sideways force on the blower, but not the Honda.  Adjust the forward speed to optimum, scream MUSH, and it just goes - very little gee hawing required.  It's important to know how to use the attitude adjustment with the Honda - keep it set right, which is easy with the handlebar control.  Taking a little getting used to when backing cause I'm still used to the wheelie - durn thing wants to run me over if I just shift it to reverse (the old wheelie disengaged reverse automatically if you didn't keep holding the reverse in, but I suppose if it came to it I'd fall backwards and the Honda would stop).  Just a minor adjustment to reflexive operating procedure required here.  'nuff said - I like it and I'd buy it again. 

tkrotchko


Location: Maryland
Joined: Feb 9, 2010
Points: 143

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #5   Jan 20, 2011 8:55 pm
Paul7 wrote:
I wonder where the sweet spot ends with tracks and maneuverability.   I mean it sounds like an in-shape 40 year old man would have no problems with tracks.  But would you recommend tracks to someone who's more advanced in years?  So lets say someone in their late fiftys...with the machine built to last 20 to 25 years,  would they still be able to handle it when they're in their seventies?


If you use your legs and hips, moving a track machine is not a problem, unless you have a specific physical limitation that prevents you from a normal level of activity. I think people want to steer it with their arms, and it becomes a more complex problem ;).
njal


Joined: Jan 9, 2010
Points: 109

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #6   Jan 20, 2011 9:25 pm
Dr.woof good luck with your new Honda.

You made a good choice on your snowblower.

njal


Joined: Jan 9, 2010
Points: 109

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #7   Jan 20, 2011 9:28 pm
Paul7 wrote:
I wonder where the sweet spot ends with tracks and maneuverability.   I mean it sounds like an in-shape 40 year old man would have no problems with tracks.  But would you recommend tracks to someone who's more advanced in years?  So lets say someone in their late fiftys...with the machine built to last 20 to 25 years,  would they still be able to handle it when they're in their seventies?



Hi Paul  this old guy is 56 ,neck surgery last year and two back

surgeries in the last 10 years,and I still man handle my machine.

kderobertis


Location: Melville, NY
Joined: Mar 9, 2010
Points: 30

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #8   Jan 20, 2011 10:00 pm
I received my Honda HS928TA in September and I wouldn't trade it for a wheeled version if I had to do it all over again.

This machine rocks and makes blowing snow fun again!

Ken

FrankMA


Location: Merrimack Valley/Northeastern Mass
Joined: Jul 1, 2010
Points: 587

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #9   Jan 21, 2011 10:02 am
Dr_Woof wrote:
Seen a lot of questions and comments on this so I'll just post my 2 cents worth.  We get a lot of HARD blown in snow around here.  Just bought a Honda HS928TCD (tracks) and I think it's night and day compared to two other wheel types I have used.  Yes, the Honda is (only slightly) harder to make a turn at the end of the line, but this is very much more than compensated for by not having to fight the blower through the first 200 yards of hard snow to get to the turn.  The Honda just pushes ahead and and is very easy to steer.

The hydrostatic drive on the Honda is good to have.  It shifts on the fly (no declutching) to adjust to any speed required do get the job done right.  The electric chute controls are wonderful - don't seem to have a problem freezing up.  When looking to buy, I found the manual chute controls on Hondas sturdily built but a bit hard to turn compared to others.  Electric....good.  WIsh the Honda had heated grips (it's -36 C here today!).

When going through lots of harder snow, the Honda engine is obviously working harder.  I compensate by slowing down forward speed or taking a partial cut - no sense in putting undue stress on the new guy, but I suppose it's only logical that more snow to move equals harder work for the engine.

The two wheelies took a lot of muscle for the hard snow - almost woulda been easier to shovel it.  My old wheelie (JD 826 with chains and "summer" tires) went thru but slowly and with difficulty and lots of muscle required.  The other new wheelie (since returned to dealer), equipped with "snow hog" type tires simply refused to touch the stuff.  I looked into getting chains for the snow hogs, but most dealers, even those that sold chains made expressly for the snow hogs, said they didn't help much (one said they made things worse!).

The Honda tracker is definitely more difficult to handle than a wheelie when in the garage on dry concrete, but I can live with that.  Maybe the suggestion of putting it on a creeper would help, but I just don't have to move it around there much anyway.  Come summer: prep it, store it and see ya next winter.

Bottom line (for me): probably almost anything will go through soft snow, but if you need to blow hard snow, get a tracked model.  I love my HS928TCD , and I imagine the new Yamahas and perhaps other tracked models (ie Ariens, but no hydrostatic drive) would work as well.



You touched upon many of the same points that I discovered when I went from a Honda HS624WA wheeled model to my new to me Honda HS928TA track model. I wish we had the option of the TCD model you guys up in CA have but I guess Honda feels we lowly Americans are not worthy :)   I did a comparative review of both in late December/early January after using my HS928TA for the first couple of times. I've always enjoyed using the hydrostaitc tranny and to be honest was very apprehensive of buying a track drive model after hearing/reading all the horror stories about the "difficulties" of a track drive snowblower. Technique (IMO) is the key to ease of use with the track drive and once this is realized, manuvering becomes just a tad more difficult than a wheel drive model. Traction is superior in every situation you described and in my case going from a 6 HP to a 9 HP was an incredible step up in performance, especially on the EOD and heavy, wet snow.

I too love my HS928TA but would hope that some day Honda (and Yamaha for that matter) wake up and realize the missed opportunity of not offering the higher end models that are available north of the border. Good luck with your new machine!

This message was modified Jan 21, 2011 by FrankMA


Toro Wheel Horse 522xi GT, Honda HS928TA, Honda HS621AS, Honda HS520A, Toro CCR3000 (work in progress), Honda HS624WA (sold 08/23/2010), Stihl BR550 Backpack Blower, Stihl MS250, McCulloch MS1635, Honda EM6500SX Generator
edgenet


If you enjoy doing it, It's not work

Location: Toronto
Joined: Nov 27, 2010
Points: 84

Re: Wheels vs Tracks and a Honda HS928TCD
Reply #10   Jan 21, 2011 11:28 am
I will take a wheeled snowblower any day over a track system. A good set of Snow-Hog tires provides excellent traction and the Snowblower can be moved around with the engine off. Nothing worse then running an engine in a closed area. Oh did I also mention the wheels are much cheaper.

If you are getting paid for what you are doing No matter how much you Enjoy it,   It's a Job
Replies: 1 - 10 of 22NextNext page of topicsAllView as Outline
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Guide   •   Discussions  Reviews  
AbbysGuide.com   About Us   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Contact Us
Copyright 1998-2024 AbbysGuide.com. All rights reserved.