Abby's Guide to Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more)
Username Password
Discussions Reviews More Guides

Member Profile


smit

Name smit
Email Address private
AIM
YIM
ICQ
Gender
Age
Location
Personal Quote
Privileges Normal user
Rank
Points 8
Number of Posts 8
Number of Reviews 0
Date Joined Nov 26, 2008
Date Last Access Dec 2, 2008 4:48 pm
smit's last  
Re: Troy-Bilt 3090 or Simplicity L9528E
#1   Nov 28, 2008 5:10 pm
AnthonyT wrote:
Thanks for your comments.  I decided to buy the 30" John Deere.  The cost was $1,499, which is more than I originally wanted to spend, but I figure I'll have it for a long time.

Congrats on the purchase!  I bough the JD 928E today.  I think the extra we've spent now will be worth it in the long run.  I paid $1300 for mine & the 1038 in my area is going for $1700.  I went looking on Wednesday and they had 3 928's.  When I went in this morning to take a final look before deciding...one of them had a sold ticket on it, another sold over the phone while I was there...leaving only one and no more coming in!  So I made an offer and he accepted.  The Toro dealer wouldn't budge off MSRP on the 826 (don't blame him, he doesn't have to, it'll be sold in the next couple days I'm sure).  SB's are so hard to get this year in Eastern Canada...anywhere really...seems to be shortages everywhere.
Re: Toro 826 O (new w/ Briggs) or JD 928E?
#2   Nov 28, 2008 12:50 pm
borat wrote:
Have you made an offer for the Simplicity 928?  You're paying more money for the larger engine and possibly different controls & heavier duty machine.  Also, did you check the auger gear case on both the JD and Simplicity?  Are they both the same?  Some of the lower end Simplicity models (8 hp) have the aluminum gear case.  The large frame models have the cast iron gear case and likely beefier gears.  All that stuff costs more.  So, the bigger Simplicity still might be a better buy.  I bought mine from a farm implement shop out in a little village not far from town.  It was the previous year's model and I got it for $1500.00 taxes included with trading in my very much used 12 year old Craftsman. 


I ended up buying the JD 928E this morning.  It does have the 305cc  Briggs.  I think it's basically the same machine as your Simplicity.  They certainly look the same and the key specs are identical. The chute rotation control & mechanism is different, the wheel/axle lock-up mechanism looks different, & different size tires seems to be all that is different.  Taxes in was $1446 CDN delivered for me. Thanks for your help :).  I hope I'm as happy with mine as you are with yours.

Re: Toro 826 O (new w/ Briggs) or JD 928E?
#3   Nov 27, 2008 9:53 pm
Confirmed today the JD 928E does indeed come with the 305cc Briggs.  The unit we were looking at had a sticker and a card that showed 249cc but a mechanic confirmed that the engine on the unit was indeed the 305cc.  So JD 928E with the 305cc Briggs or the Toro 826 with the 249cc, smaller 26" bucket, no electric start, no light, but $250 less? What would you do?

Kijiji: 2009 Toro 826 Snowthrower***NEW***

Re: Troy-Bilt 3090 or Simplicity L9528E
#4   Nov 27, 2008 5:32 pm
Please take my opinion for what it's worth...I'm about to purchase my first blower.  I have done plenty of research (online research, visited and spoke with dealers, friends, mechanics, etc) and the consensus seems to be that the quality of the Simplicity/JD/Snapper (essentially all the same machine) blowers is far superior to any MTD.  The heavier gauge steel, cast iron gear boxes, higher quality impeller & auger, and internal guts will last much longer and give you less problems than an MTD machine, Although there are many stories of MTD's lasting 15+ years it seems there are more stories similar to yours (7-10 year life) so seems like there is more risk with the MTD's.

I haven't seen the T-B you mentioned but I have seen their version of the joystick on other MTD models and it just seems flimsy and unreliable, especially compared to the design they're trying to copy...the Toro.  As for the handwarmers...I guess there's always the option of using warmer gloves or mittens?? 

For me, I know I can get more features for my money with an MTD but I'd rather pay a bit more ang get a sturdy, relaible workhorse I can count on for 15-20 years.  The JD 928E is on my shortlist, the Simplicity & Snapper are too pricey in my area, but the JD is basically the same machine (different tires & chute control is about it).  My other finalist is a bare bones Toro 826.  It has a smaller Briggs engine at 249cc, and a smaller bucket at 26" but it's also $250 less than the JD.  The Ariens 927 was on my list but is impossible to find in my area so I've given up on that unit.

Good luck with your decision.

Re: Toro 826 O (new w/ Briggs) or JD 928E?
#5   Nov 26, 2008 10:46 pm
Yup, identical cast iron gear case, auger, impeller, & bucket on the Simplicity I looked at and the JD928E.  Basically same machine other than the differences I pointed out above and the paint color, of course. I'm hoping the JD928E really does come with the 305cc and the one I saw today was an exception with the 249cc.  Will wait for a response from the dealer.  From your comments and Snowman, it seems the 305 is a better option with this 28" bucket and auger/impeller system/setup.
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Guide   •   Discussions  Reviews  
AbbysGuide.com   About Us   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Contact Us
Copyright 1998-2024 AbbysGuide.com. All rights reserved.