Abby’s Guide > Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) > Discussions > rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions |
|
br2an
Joined: Feb 8, 2005
Points: 2
|
|
rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Original Message Feb 8, 2005 9:46 pm |
|
Hi I was wondering how or where I could look up the correct engine speed for the governer on a Tecumseh 10 hp snow blower engine. It is an older Lawnboy ST1032 model (1980's). I bought it second hand a number of years ago and it has always had a tendency to rev higher than other snowblower engines that I see. It really screams like a devil when opened out (but it is still in one piece after over 15 years with me). Thanks Brian
|
Ben07
The more you know about something, the more you find there is to know.
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: Feb 26, 2004
Points: 178
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #6 Feb 10, 2005 12:36 am |
|
Hey Richie when I was reading the other techumpseh hp thread, I noticed the discussion on the jetting issue being the only difference, and the other poster saying you can not get three hp on that size engine. Both of you can be completely right. Here's how when he said you cannot get that type of increase in this size motor he is 100 percent correct, assuming you are running the motor at it's optimum horsepower in the firstplace. And I think that was the example he was referring to . racing engines on a dyno where they were trying to get more with jet adjustments etc. In that area it is hard to get more horsepower. However if you have a certain power motor like thatand somebody did a mod to the carb you can decrease horsepower with no problem and as much as you want. So if you start with a 400 horse engine , throw a carb on that reduces it to 200 then you have a lot of potentialto do high percentage increases in it like I opened up the jets and got 50 more HP.. so what I am saying is the Tech engineers may have been telling you the truth when you were quizzing them on a 8 and a 9 hp engine. Why Because it is really a potential 13 hp engine , you are not starting with an 8 and working your way up. Marketing B S AWays to get more money out of your pocket for doing nothing, And also big time to help the EPA gain controll and justify their existance Ben07
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by Ben07
Ariens 8524LE, Toro CCR2000, Jacobsen S-B S-blowers, Generac 10hp Gen-convt. to N.G., 5 L-boys(D's F's &Dura( 74,77,80,88,00), Antiq. 1960 AYP 20 in. mag w 3.5 Tech mower. Ryan/Ryobi gas Trim. AYP 205 gas blwr. Mac c-saw,Toro E-blwr, 2 Weed-E e. stg. trims. outboards, boats, util trail, 2 Jeeps
|
jubol
Location: Dover, De
Joined: Oct 3, 2003
Points: 1558
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #7 Feb 10, 2005 5:29 am |
|
Guys, If you want a chart on the Torque and HP on a HMSK100 snow King engine. Go to: "Tulsa Engine warehouse", they have it on that engine. Hope this helps!! Fred
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by jubol
Husqvarna STE927(11.5HP) snowblower, MTD Pro Series 18/42 Lawnmower, MTD 6.5 HP Self Prop Lawn Mower, Weedeater 1500 Blower, Web Gensis 2000
|
Marshall
As Long As There Are Tests, There Will Be Prayer In Public Schools. ;- )
Joined: Sep 16, 2002
Points: 7730
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #8 Feb 10, 2005 9:37 am |
|
I'll take OHV everytime over an L-Head, where available. My Kohlers have all kinds of torque and are extremely effecient engines. They seldom even lug but when they do they will lug through anything I have found. I have never had a stall. The best engines I know of are Honda's GX OHV, from 2.5HP to 24HP. They are used commercially and used in anything from pumps to generators and from snowblowers to garden tractors. Although more RPM can gain you more HP that doesn't mean you also gain more torque. Matter of fact, if you look at the chart it would suggest that by backing off the throttle to 2600 RPM's would put your max torque at the top of your operating range and you would get more benefit in the use of your OPE if, it was all about torque. Well, we know that's not right because we know our engines and equipment perform better at top engine speeds. So, logically that would mean that more HP is advantagous in the use of our equipment. We definately benefit from more torque but to believe that torque is what it's all about, is not really correct. Honda GX340
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by Marshall
|
Richie
Bring On The White Stuff
Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #9 Feb 10, 2005 11:20 am |
|
Hi Ben, Great posts and I really appreciate the information I'm also glad that Fred posted the link to the Tulsa Engine Warehouse. At least I was able to get the power curve charts I was looking for on the L-head engines. I've seen that chart on other sites, but they were not enlargable and even trying to enhance them in Photoshop, did no good. Thanks Fred Ben, unfortunately the OHV engines on that site don't have these charts listed for them. So I can't compare them to the L-heads. The one thing the charts did show is that all engines seem to have their horse power rated at a maximum engine speed of 3,600 RPM. We don't run them that fast, nor do they come from the factory set that high, so what good is it? If you were to run them at the max RPM, you have a huge torque drop-off way before that RPM, especially on a 10 HP engine. I was under the impression when I throttle my engine up to operating RPM, and in my case, I should have 8 HP working for me blowing snow. Well, not the case at all since my machine was set at the factory to run at 3,300 RPM. A dirty little secret in the OPE industry, just to name one thing. Then add the EPA carburetors into the mix, which I know for a fact rob much power, and what is left? Somehow there is a compromise between the engine RPM and torque. Mine runs great at 3,400, which reduces the maximum amount of peak torque from 12.9 to 12.3 ft. lbs according to the chart. It appears that if I wanted to run my engine, producing the most torque, I'd have to set the max speed down to 2,900 RPM's which would yield 12.9 FT. LBS. of torque. At 2,900 RPM's, my snowblower may be fine blowing 4" or 5" of snow, but it would die if used in high amounts or wet snow. As for a 10 HP L-head, the peak torque falls off after the engines passes 2,500 RPM's. As for my new carb, I really have no idea what it actually did as far as adding power, I only know it runs fantastic, so I guess that's all that matters. I'd still love to see the HP and torque curves for an equivalent OHV engine. I am very curious if they have such a large HP and torque spread as the L-heads. The bottom line here, the reason for me starting all this was to determine is it really worth spending sometimes hundreds of dollars more for that extra couple of horse power that the engine sticker says. At this point, I'm not impressed at all. Ben, Fred and the rest, thanks for sharing your knowledge. Anything else you think of, please share it
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by Richie
Richie
|
Ben07
The more you know about something, the more you find there is to know.
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: Feb 26, 2004
Points: 178
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #10 Feb 10, 2005 11:32 am |
|
Although more RPM can gain you more HP that doesn't mean you also gain more torque. . . We definately benefit from more torque but to believe that torque is what it's all about, is not really correct.
I agree with the first part of your statement as that is exactly what I said.
QUOTE "That is why when you look at charts of horsepower curves and torque curves you see almost all the torque power dives at higher rpm's and most HP curves keep climbing."
But I disagree with this part of your statement when you are using a machine such as a snowblower that can encounter a heavy load ".We definately benefit from more torque but to believe that torque is what it's all about, is not really correct."Because if you load the machine down and you hit the point where it drops the RPM's To a lower range, you will need the torque to keep it running. That's when it become a situation when it is all about torque Look at the chart you posted . Drop the rpm you went from 10 horsepower to 6 , then compare the torque curve it isn't really much of a curve it is more of a PLATEAU. real steady and strong from 2000 RPM all the way up to 2800 RPM.. this is a snowblower we are talking about. ...It is accumulating and compacting weight bearing snow at the auger then has to handle the same weight load twice when it hits the impeller and it throws it like 50 feet. Very different requirements on this machine rather than something like a lawnmower. Ben07
Because if you load the machine down and you hit the point where it drops the RPM's To a lower range, you will need the torque to keep it running. That's when it become a situation when it is all about torque Look at the chart you posted . Drop the rpm you went from 10 horsepower to 6 , then compare the torque curve it isn't really much of a curve it is more of a PLATEAU. real steady and strong from 2000 RPM all the way up to 2800 RPM.. this is a snowblower we are talking about. ...It is accumulating and compacting weight bearing snow at the auger then has to handle the same weight load twice when it hits the impeller and it throws it like 50 feet. Very different requirements on this machine rather than something like a lawnmower. Ben07
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by Ben07
Ariens 8524LE, Toro CCR2000, Jacobsen S-B S-blowers, Generac 10hp Gen-convt. to N.G., 5 L-boys(D's F's &Dura( 74,77,80,88,00), Antiq. 1960 AYP 20 in. mag w 3.5 Tech mower. Ryan/Ryobi gas Trim. AYP 205 gas blwr. Mac c-saw,Toro E-blwr, 2 Weed-E e. stg. trims. outboards, boats, util trail, 2 Jeeps
|
Ben07
The more you know about something, the more you find there is to know.
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: Feb 26, 2004
Points: 178
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #11 Feb 10, 2005 11:59 am |
|
Richie that's really OK and better that your peak torque is lower than your operating rpm.. (It's better than being there at a higher rpm that you can never get at with a machine with a governor set-up. It will be there when you need it, when you are pushing it to the limit and you put the machines rpm down it will hold itself up to the task, an don forget when you do that the governor senses the rpm drop and starts flooring the accelerator so you are really leaning into the job. and sometime people can't tell that the governor assist is opening the carb till they get done with the say 20 car driveway and their gas tank is empty. and on lesser snows they found that they used half a tank. That's when IT IS ALL ABOUT TORQUE. A rev type engine will just have to slow down in that situation, yous although under load will still maintain throwing the snow at a much faster ground speed. (and in that situation IIMOO that you will do the same overall job of a comparable engine that is built more as a horsepower engine that can sacrafice torque ,faster use less gas and creat significantly lower emissions) Ben07
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by Ben07
Ariens 8524LE, Toro CCR2000, Jacobsen S-B S-blowers, Generac 10hp Gen-convt. to N.G., 5 L-boys(D's F's &Dura( 74,77,80,88,00), Antiq. 1960 AYP 20 in. mag w 3.5 Tech mower. Ryan/Ryobi gas Trim. AYP 205 gas blwr. Mac c-saw,Toro E-blwr, 2 Weed-E e. stg. trims. outboards, boats, util trail, 2 Jeeps
|
Richie
Bring On The White Stuff
Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #12 Feb 10, 2005 12:15 pm |
|
Ben, That's why recently I've been concerning myself less with the horse power, rather with engine torque. The engine is never run to achieve the rated HP anyway, and that's a fact. At least when it comes to Briggs or Tecumseh engines, the HP/torque curve charts prove that. I also feel you are exactly correct about fuel consumption. Since I purchased this Toro, I've been blow snow in 1st gear, even when we only had 3" of the white stuff. However, when New York had that recent dumping of snow, the engine used much more fuel. It wasn't that it covered more ground, it had to remove more tons of snow. No question about the governor doing its job. I should have studied harder in Physics class, I would have understood these engine grievances much easier. Then again, if the engine specifications were more readily available, it would have answered many questions before they needed to be asked. Thanks
Richie
|
Ben07
The more you know about something, the more you find there is to know.
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: Feb 26, 2004
Points: 178
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #13 Feb 10, 2005 12:24 pm |
|
Ben, That's why recently I've been concerning myself less with the horse power, rather with engine torque. The engine is never run to achieve the rated HP anyway, and that's a fact. At least when it comes to Briggs or Tecumseh engines, the HP/torque curve charts prove that. Good way to summarize it all. In OPE it is more about torque.
Ben07
Ariens 8524LE, Toro CCR2000, Jacobsen S-B S-blowers, Generac 10hp Gen-convt. to N.G., 5 L-boys(D's F's &Dura( 74,77,80,88,00), Antiq. 1960 AYP 20 in. mag w 3.5 Tech mower. Ryan/Ryobi gas Trim. AYP 205 gas blwr. Mac c-saw,Toro E-blwr, 2 Weed-E e. stg. trims. outboards, boats, util trail, 2 Jeeps
|
jubol
Location: Dover, De
Joined: Oct 3, 2003
Points: 1558
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #14 Feb 10, 2005 12:28 pm |
|
Richie, Go to :"Small Engine Warehouse" site You can get an 11 to 13 Briggs OHV for between $350.00 and $450.00. Much better selection on Snow Engines this fall though. With a 13 Hp OHV, even with EPA controls, it ought to produce at least 10 old fashioned HP! Sure would make you blower a hot rod!! Fred
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by jubol
Husqvarna STE927(11.5HP) snowblower, MTD Pro Series 18/42 Lawnmower, MTD 6.5 HP Self Prop Lawn Mower, Weedeater 1500 Blower, Web Gensis 2000
|
Richie
Bring On The White Stuff
Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562
|
|
Re: rpm governer settings tecumseh 10 hp
Reply #15 Feb 10, 2005 12:42 pm |
|
Hi Fred, Believe me, if this engine suffers a catastrophic failure in the future, you can bet I'm going to repower this snowblower with a great engine to compliment all the other great features it has. At least the best that I'd be able to fit on it without requiring a modification to the sheet metal or polypropylene shrouds. It would really be something that would not be rated more than what the Tecumseh 11 HP OHV engine can produce, since that is the largest engine you can get on this thing. I assume that the friction disc and other components are rated to handle up to a certain amount of power, but I'd hate going beyond that, which would be very easy to do.
This message was modified Feb 10, 2005 by Richie
Richie
|
|
|