Abby’s Guide > Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) > Discussions > Honda HS928TA vs. HS624WA
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions |
|
FrankMA
Location: Merrimack Valley/Northeastern Mass
Joined: Jul 1, 2010
Points: 587
|
|
Honda HS928TA vs. HS624WA
Original Message Dec 29, 2010 7:49 am |
|
Well I finally got a chance to use my new to me Honda HS928TA after having used a Honda HS624WA for the last 10 years. The only reason I sold off the 624 was I got a really good deal on the 928 and just could not pass it up (I'm sure you guys understand!). I had been contemplating moving up to the 928 for the last few years because the EOD slop can be brutal and who does not like a few extra ponies and a little extra clearing width . The 624 handled it OK but it was slow going and pushing the motor hard so I began my search at the end of last winter and scored a sweet, low hour 2 year old unit from a friend who was relocated down south. Here's some background on my situation: Sloping asphalt paved driveway (15* or so top to bottom) about 135' long x 10' wide (for the most part) with a 40' x 50' area at the top and 20' EOD section at the bottom with a mailbox area to clear as well. The town plow always makes the first pass down the road on my side so I get a lot of the slop and cement type snow, usually 2' or so high and 6' - 8' deep. I also have to drive my blower up a small stairway section to get to the back area of my property where I need to cut a path to my back deck and clear runways to my stacked firewood piles. I also have a 12' x 40' deck but I use my new to me HS520A for that task (feedback on that at another time). Typical clean up time after a blizzard like the one we just had is in the 3 - 4 hour range and includes some areas that need to be shoveled, raking snow off of the roof of one of my sheds, detail type work, etc... Anyway, here's my observations: DISCLAIMER - I'm not slamming anyone who owns a wheel drive snowblower! - Track Drive vs. Wheel Drive: The 928 track drive is easier to use than I had been led to believe after reading all the hype. I won't say it's easy but not as bad as some have reported and definitely harder than manuevering my old wheeled 624. Overall I can see that it requires some technique to get used to and one should use the snow under the tracks as an advantage in the turning process. The snow acts as a lubricant and makes it easier to manuever than one would suspect especially if you lean your weight on the back end of the track drive using it as a quasi pivot point. Traction with the track drive was far superior to the wheel drive especially going up and down my sloped driveway and chugging through the hard pack.
- 9 HP vs. 6 HP (8.5/5.5 HP to be accurate): The 9 HP definitely produces a lot more power than I imagined it would and was considerably louder than the 6 HP. Power was consistent and smooth (for both) but the 9 HP was able to handle the heavy load without the struggle that my old 6 HP would encounter. I was able to go much faster on that first full cut pass out of the garage and EOD slop was no match for the larger engine. This allowed me to clear that first full EOD bucket load without having to go super slow and/or having to go backward/forward to make my way through. The 6 HP is a good match for most storms but the 9 HP can handle and process the heavy stuff much easier and consistently and allows you to take a wider cut than would be possible with the 6 HP.
- Bucket Height Adjustment: The 3 way bucket height adjustment allows the operator to get right down to the pavement. On my old 624, I would have to lift the rear of the machine to let the scraper bar dig in under the hardpack which would reduce the traction of the wheels. I would then resort to shuffling the bucket side to side to try to keep the bucket from riding up - this is not required with the bucket height adjustment feature on the track drive model.
- 28" Bucket vs. 24" Bucket: Other than the obvious additional 4", I did not notice any real difference in terms of manueverability. What I did notice is the larger engine allows you to take advantage of the larger clearing width of the bucket. Once again, the 9 HP can process the volume of snow much more efficiently.
I'm still getting used to operating this new toy and as such my clean up time was about the same as usual. I would think that I can cut this down a bit once I get more familiar with the nuances of operating the tracks. Overall I'm happy with my decision and feel I made the right move. My old HS624WA is still a fine machine and served me well for the last 10 years. It was a very manueverable, easy to operate machine that handled everything I threw at it. That said, I'm looking forward to taking on many snow storms with my new to me HS928TA.
This message was modified Dec 29, 2010 by FrankMA
Toro Wheel Horse 522xi GT, Honda HS928TA, Honda HS621AS, Honda HS520A, Toro CCR3000 (work in progress), Honda HS624WA (sold 08/23/2010), Stihl BR550 Backpack Blower, Stihl MS250, McCulloch MS1635, Honda EM6500SX Generator
|
FrankMA
Location: Merrimack Valley/Northeastern Mass
Joined: Jul 1, 2010
Points: 587
|
|
Re: Honda HS928TA vs. HS624WA
Reply #3 Dec 29, 2010 9:36 am |
|
Very helpful review. I hope we hear more as the season progresses. Where did the HS624 end up? Did you ever consider the HS724TA? I am interested in knowing how you set up your skids and front scraper. Did you do the "paint stir stick" setup or drop the front scraper bar all the way down to pavement. I still have not mastered the art of spinning the 928 track machine around at the end of the driveway. My back aches the next day. Some owner have opted for side skids instead of the ones behind the bucket , but I'm not sure that helps. If I could solve the aching back problem I would be 100% satisfied with the 928 TA (yes it could be a little quiter). Thank you. I placed the 624 on CL one August day when I was cleaning my garage because it kept getting in my way. I took a quick photo, posted it and it sold the next day for $ 750.00, $ 50.00 less than what I paid for it 10 years earlier! I did not consider the 7 HP as I figured 1 extra pony would not make that much of a difference. I originally began searching for either an 828 or 928 wheeled version until a friend informed me that he was being relocated and would no longer need his barely used 928TA. To be honest, I read all the horror stories about track drive snow machines and was very apprehensive about going that route. My friend assured me that the tracks were not that bad and technique was the key to manueverability. I took him for his word and am glad I did.
I never made any adjustments to either the scraper or the behind the bucket skid shoes. They were positioned the way I would have set them - scraper bar about 1/8" off the deck with the skid shoes on the deck. I'm still getting the hang of turning the 928 but it seems if you use the rear area of the track drive (closest to the handle bars) as a pivot point and apply your weight downward on the handle bars, it makes turning it in the snow a lot easier.
I'm not sure if the side mounted skid shoes would help or hurt the cause. The behind the bucket skid shoes place the shoes about 2" - 3" inside from the edges of the bucket. I found this advantageous in that the sides of the bucket could float (so to speak) over the edge of the driveway asphalt and not get hung up in the grass like the side mount skid shoes would do on my old 624.
Toro Wheel Horse 522xi GT, Honda HS928TA, Honda HS621AS, Honda HS520A, Toro CCR3000 (work in progress), Honda HS624WA (sold 08/23/2010), Stihl BR550 Backpack Blower, Stihl MS250, McCulloch MS1635, Honda EM6500SX Generator
|
kderobertis
Location: Melville, NY
Joined: Mar 9, 2010
Points: 30
|
|
Re: Honda HS928TA vs. HS624WA
Reply #4 Dec 30, 2010 8:24 pm |
|
After using my HS928TA for the first time this week, I felt applying the hydrostatic transmission in a slow forward postion makes turning very easy. This machine was amazing at the EOD when I had 2 ft of heavy wet snow and no issues passing thru, the real reason why I sold my Ariens and when with Honda with tracks. I have been completely satisfied with the results of this machine.
Ken
|
|
|