Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions

I can't figure out which model to get. My local dealer doesn't have the L1428e (the one I want) and doesn't think he can get anymore this season since he sold a bunch already. He has the three I mentioned above in stock. I like the idea of the bigger 13.5 Snow Max engine in the Signature Series. I like the Sig Series one because of the features and the Easy Turn steering. My fiancee might have to use it if I'm away and I'm traveling. I also like the construction of it but the $600 increase from the 1226 is hard to justify. Is the Easy Turn good for turning in both direction or just one. Is there a big enough difference in power between the Snow Max 13.50 and the Snow Series 11.50?

I'm not sure I want the 1226 because it has the 11.50 engine. I currently don't need anything bigger but hope to buy a house with a larger driveway in the future. I'm wondering if she could handled the the size of the 1226 if needed?

And lastly, the 1224 would definitely work for what I need now.  I'm not sure if it would work in the future but I could always sell it and get what was needed. It is appealing because of the price and that it has the same size engine as the 1226. I don't mind the manual chute control but wish it had the remote deflector.

Can anyone help me decide? This forum has been a huge help and led me to Simplicity. Now I just need to figure out which one is best and which one I actually need.

I have the P1628e and I would not do without some kind of easy turn feature again. In my experience, a larger machine with easy turn is easier to use than a smaller without. It is true that easy turn will turn easier to the right than the left but it is not impossible or even difficult to turn to the left. Maybe you don't "need" the P1524e, but I'd do yourself a favor and look elsewhere for the 1428 if that fits your needs. Alternatively you could check out the John Deere and Snappers which are both made by Simplicity/Briggs. Perhaps you could find a model in the size/price range you are looking for from one of them with easy turn. Good luck!

I was lucky enought to find a 1428 and feel the same way. I was not sure that i needed it, but the extra will always come in handy. Plus if you intend on buying a larger place then you run short on power, you will be kicking youreslef then. I also had the same concern, price wise, but in my opinon the price will be well warranted for the heavier pieces on the 1428.

As for the Snapper and the JD, I would lean more towards a Deere as they have more metal on them, the snappers that i looked at had plastic chutes, I just was not comfortable with that for more that $1000.

Search around for a 1428 and don't look back. It will fulfill all of your present needs and future needs as well providing your driveway to be isn't used as an emergency landing strip. I have a 9528 (same machine, different label). I wouldn't trade it for anything else out there short of maybe a Honda. Notice I said trade. There's no way I'd pay the ridiculous premium for the difference between a Honda and a Simplicity.

Thanks for the feedback.

I went and looked at the Snappers during lunch and wasn't impressed at all for something that is supposed to be the same machine. I looked at the Deeres again this morning and they seem in sync with the Simplicity.

Another thing that I can't decide on is the engine size. We don't get feet of snow often like some in NY or in Northern WI on here. We do get the occasional 1 footers and more. Is the 11.50 torque adequate or should I really look for the 13.50 or even the Snow Series Max? I'd rather have too much than too little and was wondering what some thought about the the difference in power IF I don't get a 1428.

Also, does the L1428e have the electric chute control? I just found a dealer with one and he said his doesn't. On their website it lists all the Large Frame models with it.

Go for the power. Try to get something with the 305cc engine. It's listed as being anything from 9 to 11 h.p. Which I find amusing. I did a parts number comparison between a 9 h.p. and an 11 h.p. engine. Every comparable part on each engine shared the identical number. So, either all of the engines are 9 h.p. or 11 h.p. I've owned a couple of 10 h.p. Tecumseh engines on two previous Craftsman snow throwers. Considering the performance of my Simplicity compared to the 10 h.p. engines, I'd say it's leaning toward 11 h.p. rather than 9.

Cuzz thats a left over model.All of the new ones have the elec chute.Try to get the price down and get the manual chute rotator.I have a simp pro w/the manual chute rotator.I got a $100 off the price in the middle of the winter.It was sitting to an identical model w/the elec chute rotator.I prefer a simple machine with less of a chance of breaking down when I need it most.

I just got back from checking out another snow blower. This time it was a Snapper 1428 ... which I thought was supposed to be almost identical to the Simplicity 1428. I had looked at a Snapper 1428 at another dealer last week and it sure didn't look the same as the one I saw today. This one had a manual chute control whereas the one I saw last week had an electric chute control. What's up with that???

Also for what it's worth, I asked today's dealer his thoughts on electric chute controls. He told me that he used to carry some MTD models a few years ago that had that feature and they were nothing but trouble ... so he doesn't carry them anymore. He said that moisture would get inside where the wiring was and create all kinds of problems.

I tell ya, shopping for a snow blower can be very confusing!

(By the way, I don't mean to dissuade anybody from buying the Simplicity 1428, but since I just heard this today [from a store owner no less], I thought it might be good info to pass along. I really don't know how much "weight" to put into the dealer's comments. I'm hoping the knowledgeable people here can help sort through this).

go with the I1224E. according to a dealer i know, he says same engine, lighter machine. i'm gonna buy one 850.00.

My advice is to stay away from the electric chute rotator and go with the manual. Electricity and water don't mix. Frankly I think it is a little silly to have a "Joystick" control on a snow blower. Remember that snowblowers are used in the worst of conditions and frigid temperatures, blowing snow and ice are bound to freeze up an electric chute rotator. When buying s snowblower it's best to keep things simple and avoid the frills.

Summerwinds wrote:
Making waaaaaaay too much sense.

so what not to like on the L1224E same engine as 1226 lighter and easier to menuver about 8 hp which should be strong enough for any job. real good price so why spend more and get the job done with this model at hundreds less. simplicity quality.