Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions

I'm buying a new snowblower in the smaller size for a driveway and sidewalk. Can anyone comment on the Simplicity 522E or Honda HS520C please? These are both single stage and compact for good storage.

A lot depends on where you live, clearing conditions and the snow conditions.
1
If you get decent amounts of snow each year and it’s generally wet or heavy snow like in eastern Massachusetts then single stages are not the best. They do well in 1-5 inch snowfalls but not so well above that. The end of the driveway pile is an issue also.
2.
They pull themselves along by their rubber tipped augers. A metal main auger has rubber pieces attached which handle the snow and pull the snowblower along. Each turn of the auger the rubber touching the ground pulls the snowblower a small portion of an inch. That causes wear and the rubber tips are fairly expensive.
3.
Because they pull themselves along they work best on flat driveways. On rough driveways of dirt, stone, tiles, brick and any other rough surface they are tough to use. The rough driveways cause problems for the augers and the pulling along part.
4.
You have to maintain by hand the angle of the snowblower so the augers don’t pull to fast or not pull at all. The blades just want to lightly touch the driveway and only that position to make drive work.
5.
They are very nice at tossing great distances, even 3 horsepower units. They toss light snow and slush very well. They don’t do so well with the EOD or double tossed snow because it’s packed and hard to drive into. The pull by the augers does not supply much forward push into bigger or packed snow.
6.
Compactness is a strong point for them. Small footprint and folding handles make storage easy.
7.
They are pretty easy to use BUT for higher snows or the EOD pile you’ll probably have to push it to make it clear. Depending on your snows you may have to break down the EOD by hand so it can gather it.
8.
A small two stage can come close to the storage footprint of a single stage and a consideration to check out. There are models available that have drive wheels, 20-22 inch cut, 5hp motors, and folding handles. I think MTD makes a 5.5hp 22 inch cut machine they pretty small compared to a “regular” two stage.
9.
Honda anything versus the rest of the worlds products – Honda. Simplicity uses a Briggs & Stratton engine. The Honda uses a GC series Honda engine. I’d rather have a GX series Honda in there but still take the home owner grade GC over a Briggs.

Nice work Trouts. You are definitely thorough.

trouts2 wrote:
I agree with your post except for this.  GX motors are heavenly - GC motors are crap.  I'd take a hampster in a wheel over a GC - just my opinion.

Great post.

I have a HS621 with the GX160 engine. I love that engine. I'm going to hang on this machine as long as I can. If Honda USA still markets this snowblower, it would be selling for $1300. Yikes.

superbuick wrote:
U gonna need a lot of hamsters. :)

superbuick wrote:
I've only used the GX series Honda engines. Honda aren't doing much for their reputation by producing the GC series engines, in my opinion. I'll take a B&S IC series engine over a GC but I'd hazard to guess that the aluminum bore B&S engines are probably similar in quality to the Honda GC. I'm not certain of this because I've never done an A-B comparison. Given that the aluminum bore engines are B&S lower end units, it's not much of a stretch to believe that they aren't much better than the GC. Anyone know for sure?

GASK wrote:
Have you looked at or considered a Toro 221QR?  Or you only want a single stage with a 4-stroke engine?

aa335 wrote: I'd also recommend looking at the 221 Toro.  I'm not hesitant to say it is far and away the best single stage snowblower currently on the market.  Its worth a look.  The Toro auger/housing design throws snow incredibly well.  If you insist on 4 stroke (aka insisting on less power, more weight, and more maintenance) then check out the 421 Toro. 

Sure appeciate all the replies and information. I thought I wanted just a 4-stroke, one-stage. I'm limited to its storage space. Also, we don't get a lot of snow where I live; however, there are those days!!! Also, I hav a large driveway but a small sidewalk, so it's primarily to clear away the snow on the driveway and the mess the street cleaners leave right at the end of the driveway. My driveway is cement and it's pretty much clear of any debris that would get in the blades.

Is the Toro a 2-stroke? I recall a video on YouTube of an older small Toro ploughing through snow in the woods and it was incredible. Just never wore out and really cleared the snow.

Any other thoughts on this would be appreciated.

The Toro 221 series (and the 210) are 2 strokes.  They are VERY underrated at 6.5hp, lightweight, reliable, and very easy to start.  The Toro 421, Snapper, and Honda are 4 strokes that are marketed as superior but in reality are more complex, heavier, weaker, and require regular oil changes.  The common knock against 2 strokes is the "messy mixing of oil and gas"- this is a complete load of crap.  If you can make a cup of tea, coffee, or lemonade, then you can mix oil and gas.  You buy a gallon of gas, then dump the pre-measured bottle of 2 stroke oil (included with the snowblower and available at any hardware store, home depot, lowes, etc.) into the gallon of gas.  Done.  MUCH easier than changing the oil in your 4 stroke motor each season.

When it comes to single stage snowblowers, I'm partial to 2 strokes and also to the Toro auger design.  I've run the Honda 520 quite a bit, but never the snapper (though I used an old MTD that had the same auger design and it isn't very good).  In back to back comparisons, the Toro 2 stroke out threw the Honda handily.  I've never run the Toro 4 stroke, but with the way the 2 stroke performs I can't see a need to.