Abby's Guide to Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more)
Username Password
Discussions Reviews More Guides
Abby’s Guide > Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) > Discussions > My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower

Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions

Search For:
goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Original Message   Nov 27, 2008 2:37 pm
Hello All.

Here are my few complaints about my Ariens 1130DLE snow thrower. Over the last few weeks I have been getting my snowthrower ready for the years to come. After realizing how much it rusted in just one year, I figured it was best to start sooner then later.  I am super glad I started this now as some things haven't been easy. Like the removal of one rusted wheel to the axle. Anyway, won't rehash that here as its in the other post about it.

Here are my complaints. I really don't see why they should even be a issue with such a well built machine.  My first complaint is lack on anti seeze on integral components that should be easy to remove for maintenance.  Today I spent some time taking off the attachment pulleys (two bolted together for dual belts). I did this after reading how hard it could be to remove after a few years of operation. Things like gear pulleys, heat and hammering to remove it, seem to be common.  So why not anti seeze it?  Maybe they do, but after getting mine off today, certainly no indication it was done on mine. Granted mine wasn't that rusted and came off without much trouble, but it was rusting. Few more years and I am sure I would be in the same boat as the rest when it comes to tough removal.  So why not the few extra dollars to anti seeze these components?

My second complaint.  All the rakes that hold the bushings are screwed in with self tapping bolts. When you purchase the rake there is no thread in it, so you screw in the bolts which grab into the rake. I cannot understand why the rakes would not have threads? Why not a bolt with a nut on the end? Why is this a issue for me? Well I cannot seem to back out a bolt without snapping off the head. Then, I am stuck either purchasing another rake or trying to removing the broken bolts, which isn't easy.  I cannot understand why these rakes are not made so that they can come off easier with better bolt system. If somebody here has a trick on removing these self tapping bolts, please let me know. PB blaster does not seem to help at all. Just as a note, the rake is $9.95 and the bolts are $1.45 at my dealer. So with three bolts in each, it doesn't take much to need $15 in parts for just one rake.  With two on the auger, it will run me over $30 to get it out if I want to anit seeze it.  At least when I put it back together I can use bolts/nut. But would be nice if there was a thread in the rake.

That is it. These seem to be minor issues that ariens could easily rectify to make these machines easy to maintain. 

Cheers
Goofie Newfie
This message was modified Nov 27, 2008 by goofienewfie


Cheers
Goofie Newfie
Replies: 1 - 25 of 25View as Outline
pvrp


Joined: Nov 14, 2008
Points: 151

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #1   Nov 27, 2008 3:09 pm
goofienewfie wrote:
My second complaint.  All the rakes that hold the bushings are screwed in with self tapping bolts.
When you purchase the rake there is no thread in it, so you screw in the bolts which grab into the
rake. I cannot understand why the rakes would not have threads? Why not a bolt with a nut on the end?

I'm sure this is a cost-cutting thing because it saves a few seconds when the machine is
assembled and saves a few nuts per machine.  There is probably also less chance of  the
screws coming loose from vibration, though on my 1999 Ariens there are bolts with nuts
in these positions. 

Rust and vibration don't go well together.  You can grease everything (I always dip a bolt or
nut in thick waterproof grease when re-installing it) but this could make it easier for the
thing to unscrew from the vibration.  You also have to be careful not to overtighten the part
since it's easier to turn, but not turning it enough almost guarantees that it will vibrate off.

I notice that those screws are awfully small, which doesn't help.

Paul    (who's not terribly fond of bean counters)
This message was modified Nov 27, 2008 by pvrp
goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #2   Nov 27, 2008 3:43 pm
pvrp wrote:
I'm sure this is a cost-cutting thing because it saves a few seconds when the machine is
assembled and saves a few nuts per machine.  There is probably also less chance of  the
screws coming loose from vibration, though on my 1999 Ariens there are bolts with nuts
in these positions. 

Rust and vibration don't go well together.  You can grease everything (I always dip a bolt or
nut in thick waterproof grease when re-installing it) but this could make it easier for the
thing to unscrew from the vibration.  You also have to be careful not to overtighten the part
since it's easier to turn, but not turning it enough almost guarantees that it will vibrate off.

I notice that those screws are awfully small, which doesn't help.

Paul    (who's not terribly fond of bean counters)

That's what I was thinking, tho I am hoping that is not correct.  I paid good money for this machine and to find out that it was to save time and money, wouldn't seem right for this amount. I would happily pay more for things to be done right, the reason why I bought the ariens.

Yes, I agree. grease everything. I will keep a eye on things to ensure it doesn't unscrew/vibrate off.  Talking about grease, what grease do you use for moving parts, Like the gears? What is a good grease for low temps?

As for over tighten the part making it easier to turn, I am not sure I understand that part. You mean easier to get off later?

Yes the screws are small, a more robust screw would probably even do, ever tho I would perfer a bolt and nut.

lol, I am not fond of bean counters either, specially counting on a machine you don't expect it on.

Cheers

Cheers
Goofie Newfie
pvrp


Joined: Nov 14, 2008
Points: 151

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #3   Nov 28, 2008 12:02 am
goofienewfie wrote:
I would happily pay more for things to be done right, the reason why I bought the ariens.

Me too.  At least Ariens still appears to be the best of the best.  I find it hard to believe that no
one else offers models with a differential.  I couldn't imagine being without it.  I'm anxious to
see how the new limited slip one works, it'll be nice not to stick my nose into the exhaust pipe
everytime I want to lock the wheels.

It's too bad that the old farm implement philosophy of making things to last forever seems to
be quickly disappearing, if it's not already gone.  Now it's all about figuring out what is the
minimum required to generate X number of sales while providing the shortest lifespan the
customer will accept.  Maybe Ariens should open up a custom shop so we could specify the
features we wanted :-)  And pay for it.  For example, I would really like the most power for the
narrowest auger width.  My dream Ariens is a battery electric start 13hp 24" blower.


Talking about grease, what grease do you use for moving parts, Like the gears? What is a good grease for low temps?

Do you have Canadian Tire in Newfoundland ?  Here's a grease they sell that would be ideal :

   http://www.canadiantire.ca/browse/product_detail.jsp?%3Eprd_id=845524443278235

Product data sheet from Shell :

http://www-static.shell.com/static/ca-en/downloads/shell_for_businesses/oils_lubricants/1-17.pdf


As for over tighten the part making it easier to turn, I am not sure I understand that part. You mean easier to get off later?

I meant that if you're used to applying a certain amount of torque tightening a screw or bolt
(after having broken a sufficient number of them to acquire a sort of torque-wrench-of-the-
wrist) applying grease will throw off your calibration and you have to tighten less than you're
used to or risk going too far.

Paul

This message was modified Nov 28, 2008 by pvrp
goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #4   Nov 28, 2008 9:30 am
Hi Paul;

Yes, that make total sense now about not over tighten the greased bolt. Thanks for explaining that for me.  That grease looks good, will have to pick up a tube on what now seems to be my daily visit to Canadian tire.  Just a note, you CT link did not work for me, but I found it when I searched their site.  Thanks

Cheers
Goofie Newfie
goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #5   Nov 28, 2008 4:11 pm
Picked up a tube of that grease today. Have to say thanks for the advice, what a great grease. Very silky between the fingers, feels like great quality.  Thanks!

Cheers
Goofie Newfie
borat


Joined: Nov 10, 2007
Points: 2692

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #6   Nov 28, 2008 8:17 pm
pvrp wrote:
Me too.  At least Ariens still appears to be the best of the best. 

By reading the very frequent complaints about Ariens machines, I have to say "best of the best" is a considerable over statement.   In my opinion, they're in the top five of the best snow throwers.  However, I'd rate them in around fourth after Honda, Simplicity/Snapper/JD, Toro.   They're not the machines they used to be.

This message was modified Nov 28, 2008 by borat
pvrp


Joined: Nov 14, 2008
Points: 151

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #7   Nov 28, 2008 10:55 pm
borat wrote:
 In my opinion, they're in the top five of the best snow throwers.  However, I'd rate them in
around fourth after Honda, Simplicity/Snapper/JD, Toro.  They're not the machines they used to be.

I was expecting someone to bring Honda up, but not the others.  I haven't gotten
up close with all of them but from pictures and specs I don't see what would lower
Ariens with respect to the others, but then I'm only referring to their Pro models and
how they compare with the top models of the other companies.   It looks to me that
solidity-wise the Ariens is at least the equal of the others, if not more so, but the big
thing that puts Ariens way ahead of the others is the differential.

As for Honda...  I have to admit that to me the idea of Honda making a snowblower
in the first place is kind of a strange idea and their implementation of it reflects this. 
It's like using a GoldWing to plow a field.  In my mind a snowblower should be more
like an old tractor, few parts (inexpensive to replace) and everything built so that it
could be left for a few years at the end of a field but then be put back in service with
little effort.  Big lumbering heavy parts, the very opposite of spiffy Japanese mechanics.
Something you can work on yourself without needing thousands of dollars of special
tools.  Honda's front end has never impressed me either, too light and somehow
doesn't look quite right (and they only recently fixed their weird skid shoes, or lack
thereof).

Cars are a different matter, I drive Japanese, but for snowblowing I'd rather have a
Harley :-)  I get a kick out of starting my 10hp Tecumseh flathead.  Chug, chug, chug,
sputter, chug, chug, chug.  What vibration, what noise !   But after ten years it's still
like the day I bought it and will probably be the same in another ten, or twenty.

Then there's the price of parts.  I have this Honda four-stroke brush cutter.  I wanted
to buy another head so I could switch from a blade to a string with a single screw
instead of having to spend a bunch of time dismantling and reassembling things to
switch from one to the other.  The price for a second head (minus the guards,spool
and so on) was almost the price of the entire machine. Imagine the price for parts
and repair to Honda's hydrostatic drive.

I have a 1995 Case 1845C skidsteer loader which is also built the American way,
every part is overly robust and its four-cylinder C-u-mmins [this software won't let
me put those three letters together] diesel always starts like a car when I fire it up,
even in winter.  All parts are readily available and cheap.  Just like Ariens.  By the
way this machine, with chains, is a real snowmover (though I bought it for
landscaping).   I've noticed that skidsteer loaders have also gone the route of
decreasing robustness and increased complexity.  Too bad.

To you Honda owners, I'm not trying to pick a fight :-)  I seriously considered buying
one this year but the fact that they won't turn on a dime was the main fault since it
will be used to clear a lengthy wheelchair ramp with u-turns and a tracked machine
would have been a pain (now if their tracks could be operated like the wheels of my
loader, which can spin on itself, it would be a different matter). I may still buy one
oneday (in another life I was a Honda motorcycle mechanic) but if I do it will be more
like buying a motorcycle or sporstcar,  for the fun of babying it  and working on it in my 
garage to keep it shiny new.  While the Ariens spends the night in the doghouse.

Paul
This message was modified Nov 29, 2008 by pvrp
coasteray


El Toro! 1028 LXE
Tecumseh 358cc
10hp


Location: NE Washington State
Joined: Mar 3, 2008
Points: 142

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #8   Nov 29, 2008 3:22 am
goofienewfie wrote:
Hello All.

Here are my few complaints about my Ariens 1130DLE snow thrower. Over the last few weeks I have been getting my snowthrower ready for the years to come. After realizing how much it rusted in just one year, I figured it was best to start sooner then later.  I am super glad I started this now as some things haven't been easy. Like the removal of one rusted wheel to the axle. Anyway, won't rehash that here as its in the other post about it.

Here are my complaints. I really don't see why they should even be a issue with such a well built machine.  My first complaint is lack on anti seeze on integral components that should be easy to remove for maintenance.  Today I spent some time taking off the attachment pulleys (two bolted together for dual belts). I did this after reading how hard it could be to remove after a few years of operation. Things like gear pulleys, heat and hammering to remove it, seem to be common.  So why not anti seeze it?  Maybe they do, but after getting mine off today, certainly no indication it was done on mine. Granted mine wasn't that rusted and came off without much trouble, but it was rusting. Few more years and I am sure I would be in the same boat as the rest when it comes to tough removal.  So why not the few extra dollars to anti seeze these components?

My second complaint.  All the rakes that hold the bushings are screwed in with self tapping bolts. When you purchase the rake there is no thread in it, so you screw in the bolts which grab into the rake. I cannot understand why the rakes would not have threads? Why not a bolt with a nut on the end? Why is this a issue for me? Well I cannot seem to back out a bolt without snapping off the head. Then, I am stuck either purchasing another rake or trying to removing the broken bolts, which isn't easy.  I cannot understand why these rakes are not made so that they can come off easier with better bolt system. If somebody here has a trick on removing these self tapping bolts, please let me know. PB blaster does not seem to help at all. Just as a note, the rake is $9.95 and the bolts are $1.45 at my dealer. So with three bolts in each, it doesn't take much to need $15 in parts for just one rake.  With two on the auger, it will run me over $30 to get it out if I want to anit seeze it.  At least when I put it back together I can use bolts/nut. But would be nice if there was a thread in the rake.

That is it. These seem to be minor issues that ariens could easily rectify to make these machines easy to maintain. 

Cheers
Goofie Newfie


I'm thinking that maybe you could contact Ariens via their web site and give them your feedback in precise terms.  Maybe they will take the advice to make some changes in these areas you've mentioned.  Certainly the bolts could come with nuts if they wanted to manufacture the parts in question that way.  I think it would be a good idea.  It's also a good idea about treating the parts to prevent rust.  If you contact them, please let us know what Ariens' response is.  That would be very helpful. 

  El Toro! 1028 LXE - Tecumseh 358cc 10hp   Let it snow! Let it snow! Let it snow!
mech12


Joined: Feb 20, 2006
Points: 273

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #9   Nov 29, 2008 8:56 am
  this is how  the companies make there money....  im surprised no one on this forum has mentioned it in the past.  when you purchase a new machine " disassemble" and anti-seize stuff.  my small engine teacher here in minnesota worked for the polaris dealer and the upper people told him this exactly,  that this is how the make they money is selling parts later.    take briggs and stratton..... right now we are sellin g a 5hp vertical mower engine for $139.00.   2 yrs down the road from proper maintenance, i will sell him a new $40.00 carb plus gaskets and such.   get the point.   
Moderator Denis


Location: CAN
Joined:
Points: 638

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #10   Nov 29, 2008 10:21 am
mech12 wrote:
  this is how  the companies make there money....  im surprised no one on this forum has mentioned it in the past.  when you purchase a new machine " disassemble" and anti-seize stuff.  my small engine teacher here in minnesota worked for the polaris dealer and the upper people told him this exactly,  that this is how the make they money is selling parts later.    take briggs and stratton..... right now we are sellin g a 5hp vertical mower engine for $139.00.   2 yrs down the road from proper maintenance, i will sell him a new $40.00 carb plus gaskets and such.   get the point.   


Yep! same thing everywhere and most in China. I always make my wife smile about China, when I go to Walmart to buy something to hang on the wall they always come with screws....yeah screws chineese screws, if you miss your first shot they strip right away, that's how thing are made now, zinc plated sounds good but you know what is really zinc? it's crappy steel :)))))))))))))  So to get competitive to asiatic we now north american made our stuff like them what a mess, we are far from the tough steel 1959 ford truck


goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #11   Nov 29, 2008 1:56 pm
Hi all;

My complaints here are relativily minor. But, none the less unexpected for the price paid for this machine. In any case it is fixable, just with some work and money involved. My case being that for  just a few more dollars and a tad bit more time, these would not have to be address by any owner for a few years and that is what most expect with this type of machine. Has this ruin my Ariens experience? No. I suspect that what I have done to this machine would have been needed on almost all machines. Borat, in a post to me you explained you had to anti seize your wheels, as for the pulleys you didn't mention. I am currious to know why you ranking system? What makes your machine and torro better then ariens?  I won't mention the honda, as I too believe this to be number one.  The main differences I know of the simplicity/snapper/JD are the briggs engine and the cast iron gear case. But what else? The Toro is aluminum.  This brings me to another question, what is the makes the cast iron so good? I know its heavy are probably last longer, unsure if age of it lasting will make a difference in the end as I think the heavy aluminum one on mine will withlast fairly well. The Pro's have a cast iron, but my is just slightly less then a pro model. But isn't what makes a good gear is the gears inside and not so much the case? Why all the talk about the cover? I am thinking it would be better if we could compare the gears inside. Maybe the cover does make a difference, I am new to all this.

The negatives to me right now for ariens are the tecumseh engine and the minor issues I posted about in the beginning of this thread. Other then that I have no issues.  As for the tecumseh, well most here tell me it will last a long time with proper care, this including yourself. So that doesn't seem to be much of a issue. I am guessing Ariens will be moving on to Briggs in the future, so that sort of  crosses that off for the future, at least I hope.

But there are some pros on the ariens that your simplicity doesn't have. For example, the differential.  I think this is amazing and truly enjoyed this feature last year. The simplity has wheel trigger and I believe on one side at that. I think that is less then superior to the differential.  Second I am unsure of, but does the simplicity have a dual belt drive system for the impeller and auger? I think this is a great feature as well. 

I think there are pros and cons to every machine, I think the ranking of the top 5 may change depending on ones needs. I am not sure if its clear cut as to what manufacture is in which place.  I have never used or even seen a simplicity/snapper/jd.  Last year Jd didn't have snow throwers. Simplicity or snapper is not sold in my area. So I cannot even really judge them in any way. I have seen and used Toro and I can honestly say I feel my ariens is better for my purposes then a toro.  Toro was more expensive as well when I was pricing comparable machines last year before I purchased this unit.

I am sure the ranking of the top five could be debatable for a long time and maybe it would certainly change depending on each persons needs.  But I would like to know the things I have listed here as to why you put them in that order for yourself.

As for the original topic, I would love to see Arien's address the issues I listed and maybe I will forward this off to their customer service. If I get a response I will be sure to let you know.

Cheers
Goofie Newfie
borat


Joined: Nov 10, 2007
Points: 2692

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #12   Nov 30, 2008 8:59 pm
I didn't want to start a pis* fight over which snow thrower is best.  My point was that  from what I've read lately,  in my opinion, Ariens is not  "best of the best".   I came to my conclusions by doing a cursory count of the number of complaints about Ariens vs. the others.  If you do the same, you'll see that the ratio of complaints is very much biased toward Ariens machines.  I'm certain that the argument will be made that Ariens is the number one seller of snow throwers.  Therefore the higher number of complaints.   That may have some impact on the weighting but I doubt very much that the numbers would be sufficient to balance the complaints bias.  I will make one concession though and that is since Ariens & Toro began selling their lower end products in the box stores, it is very much possible that some of their problems are a result of poor assembly. 

My rating of Ariens is based on my observations of words associated with complaints, used in conjunction with the word Ariens.   Not scientific I know.  However, I've been around long enough to see a trend developing. 

goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #13   Dec 1, 2008 10:41 am
borat wrote:
I didn't want to start a pis* fight over which snow thrower is best.  My point was that  from what I've read lately,  in my opinion, Ariens is not  "best of the best".   I came to my conclusions by doing a cursory count of the number of complaints about Ariens vs. the others.  If you do the same, you'll see that the ratio of complaints is very much biased toward Ariens machines.  I'm certain that the argument will be made that Ariens is the number one seller of snow throwers.  Therefore the higher number of complaints.   That may have some impact on the weighting but I doubt very much that the numbers would be sufficient to balance the complaints bias.  I will make one concession though and that is since Ariens & Toro began selling their lower end products in the box stores, it is very much possible that some of their problems are a result of poor assembly. 

My rating of Ariens is based on my observations of words associated with complaints, used in conjunction with the word Ariens.   Not scientific I know.  However, I've been around long enough to see a trend developing. 


Hi borat;

Please do not take my post as a fight over which snow thrower is best.  As for Ariens being the best, I do not agree with this either and I own one. The point behind my post was coming from a person that is new to all this. I am a one year old snow thrower owner and have much to learn. This forum has been a wealth of information for me and has helped me from deciding my purchase to maintaining it. Actually your post have helped me a great deal and for that I very much appreciate it. The purpose behind my post wasn't to bite the hand that feeds me. The purpose was to get you to elaborate more on your thought process into your conclusion of order on the top five machines.  I was hoping you would go into detail about each machine features, rather then general conclusion based on post.  Since I have never seen a simplicity, I was curios to things like gear casing, engine, bearings, bushings, bolts, pulleys, differential, zerks, etc...  Get down to a nitty gritty analyst of the machines that make the world of difference in the end. Basing it on this information would seem a more thorough way of compiling a list of order. 

Last year when I bought this machine I was thinking of writing a review. Then I backed out on it, thinking that a year of running and the end maintenance would make a difference. It most certainly has. After having some problems and some interventions as to the way things are assembled, I can certainly say my review will be different. I am planning on doing one. I noticed a while back that your review was slightly updated, but never went into more maintenance specific details. After you serviced your machine is there anything you disliked on it? Or is everything up to spec and exactly how you would have it.

As for Ariens selling more machines, thus more complaints. Well I think this may have a slight impact. I know in my area I cannot get a simplicity/snapper. So there has to be more areas like that.  I am not exactly remote. I do live in the capital of my province and has a decent population; we also receive large amounts of snow. The snow thrower market is a good market here.

So sorry if my post came off as my machine is better, that wasn't my intention at all. I was just hoping for some details on machine comparison. Like the original post said, I am not completely happy with my machine, based on a couple of minor issues that I believe Ariens could resolve. That is at this point and maybe more things may arise, I can assure you, I will let you know. I am not going to hold back for the sake of being able to say I own ARIENS! Nothing better! :) 

Side note, I did forward these complaints off to ariens. I think I did so four times. Not on purpose. There contact form kept giving a sql error or something. Tried it twice in firefox and twice in explorer. Then I give up. Checked my e-mail later. Got four automatic replies from Ariens saying they received my e-mail. lol, I am sure four of them will catch somebody’s eye. haha.. Will keep you informed as to if I receive response.



Cheers
Goofie Newfie
borat


Joined: Nov 10, 2007
Points: 2692

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #14   Dec 1, 2008 8:49 pm
Don't fret about the possibility of me being offended.  I'm not.    It's nothing  you said that I'm objecting to.   It was the "best of the best" quote that I found more than a little pretentious.   Trust me, I believe that Ariens make some of the finest machines out there.  Particularly their Pro models.   Anything less than that are, more or less on par with , or slightly less robust than comparable models from Toro, Snapper/Simplicity and their derivatives.   The main points that differentiated the lesser Ariens from the Simplicity/Snapper models  was the Tecumseh engine and aluminum gear case.   However, that appears to be changing.  I've noticed that Simplicity is going with aluminum gear cases on their small 8 h.p. models.  Their large frame models, 9 h.p. & up still have the cast iron gear case. 

Regarding your questions concerning what I like/don't like about the Simplicity, that'll be a brief synopsis.  I like everything about it other than the reverse speed.  It's painfully slow.  Other than that, everything works well and I've had no problems with freezing controls, rusting parts or anything else for that matter.  Now, that does not automatically equate to it being a better machine.  It's as good as the best brands out there and I'll stand by my ratings primarily due to the features (durable mechanical controls, B&S engine, cast iron gear case, very solid chassis, all metal mechanical components ) that, to me, make it a slightly preferable machine.  Much mechanical failure can be attributed to maintenance.   Or more correctly, lack thereof.   I'm certain that very many, if not most, purchasers of first class snow throwers, do nothing to them simply because it's an ???? machine.  People get false sense of invincibility because the have bought one of the best.   Not so.  When I bought my Simplicity, I knew it was a very well crafted machine but anything made on a factory assembly line should be given a thorough inspection once you get it home.  Even on the Simplicity, I found things that I wasn't happy with.  Mostly lubrication issues.  No grease on the drive chains, no grease between axle and wheels other than the driven wheel engagement mechanism and generally dry control cables and other mechanical interfaces.   So, with a bit of initial attention, many problems can be eliminated before they happen.  A note of caution though.  Don't get too goofy with oil & grease anywhere near the friction/drive wheel and drive belt surfaces.   Slopping grease or oil on those surfaces will be very, very inconvenient. 

I hope I've addressed your queries. 

         

pvrp


Joined: Nov 14, 2008
Points: 151

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #15   Dec 5, 2008 11:35 pm
borat, I wasn't really being pretentious, though it may have come
across that way.  It probably was a bit of a challenge, but mainly
just some rooting for the home team.

I've come to the realization that snowblowers aren't really for the
average person, which may account for their apparent slide towards
extinction.  The fact that they are getting cheaper and cheaper,
therefore requiring more and more maintenance certainly doesn't
help the situation.

Take for instance the requirement that the oil be changed on a new
machine after 2 hours of operation.  How many new owners would
know how to do this ? (especially since when you go to remove the
plug/cap it's the entire pipe that unscrews and then you need visegrips
and, well, it's a real pain).  But I can't see someone paying a dealer to
come over and work on the machine after a couple of hours, and if
it was bought in a big box store there is no one to come over.  Once a
year maybe, and even then most people wait for the thing to break
before seeking help.

I think the handyman (I've yet to meet a handywoman) may be on
the way out as well, at least in my part of the woods, and you more
or less have to be one to take care of outdoor power equipment.

So maybe we'll all be forced down the Honda path where you pay
a fortune for the machine then pay a fortune to have it maintained
by a dealer, just like a car.  I don't think the cheap snowblower can
survive as a disposable commodity, they're just too expensive for
that.  Unlike something like a lawnmower.  The snowblower of
yesterday could be treated like a lawnmower because it lasted,
and could be fixed for a reasonable price when it broke.

The problem with the Honda route is that  we're not all rich enough
for it, and like I said before I don't find fancy mechanics well suited
for hard work.  So maybe we'll be forced to go back to hiring the
local kid on the block if we can drag him away from his computer ?

Paul
This message was modified Dec 5, 2008 by pvrp
nibbler


Joined: Mar 5, 2004
Points: 751

Borat - Iron Gear Case
Reply #16   Dec 6, 2008 9:02 am
I've participated in another thread where it seems that the current Ariens cast Iron gear case has pretty well the same internal parts as the aluminium one. Those parts seem similar to the original aluminium case as opposed to the cast iron one. In particular the two rolloer thrust bearing seem to be missing. Do you know if Simplicity has done anything like that?
borat


Joined: Nov 10, 2007
Points: 2692

Re: Borat - Iron Gear Case
Reply #17   Dec 6, 2008 10:51 am
nibbler wrote:
I've participated in another thread where it seems that the current Ariens cast Iron gear case has pretty well the same internal parts as the aluminium one. Those parts seem similar to the original aluminium case as opposed to the cast iron one. In particular the two rolloer thrust bearing seem to be missing. Do you know if Simplicity has done anything like that?



Are you asking me if Simplicity have removed the thrust bearings (normally found the cast gearbox) from their aluminum gear box internals?  I don't know for sure but, if I were a betting man, I'd say probably.  The gear boxes are likely outsourced.  If they buy from the same source as Ariens & Toro, I'd venture to say it's the same set up.   Under normal use, the more robust aluminum  cased gear boxes should hold up.  My of Craftsman had them and they never failed in a combined twenty years of service.   However, as some have previously posted, heavy duty cast iron gear boxes and more robust internals will withstand the "beyond normal use" punishment.   That's the difference between a ten year service machine and a twenty or thirty or beyond year service machine. 

Unfortunately, we can readily see the downward sliding curves of cost and quality.  They go hand in hand.   What I find particularly irritating is the illusion that some of the premium brand names are trying to pull over on the consumer.  They still flaunt their superiority reputation, demand prices that at one time reflected true quality but no longer deliver the goods they did, even a mere ten years ago.  They want top dollar for a mediocre product.   Those of us who are familiar with and have had good experience  with these "top brand" names had developed a trust and loyalty toward their products.   While the loyalty of many remains, many of the products no longer deserve it.     

This message was modified Dec 6, 2008 by borat
nibbler


Joined: Mar 5, 2004
Points: 751

Re: Borat - Iron Gear Case
Reply #18   Dec 7, 2008 11:16 am
borat wrote:

While the loyalty of many remains, many of the products no longer deserve it.     


Thats what I'm beginning to worry about. What really concerns me about the whole thing is the essentially cosmetic change of the outter covering. If the internals are the same then in my mind the performance will be almost identical.
pvrp


Joined: Nov 14, 2008
Points: 151

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #19   Dec 7, 2008 11:51 am
nibbler wrote:
Thats what I'm beginning to worry about. What really concerns me about the whole thing is the essentially cosmetic change
of the outter covering. If the internals are the same then in my mind the performance will be almost identical.

I'd say it's the other way around.  I think you're talking only about the gearcase but the issue is
more general than that.  On the outside, apart from the ridiculous square auger outlet, the machine
(and the gearcase) looks to be just as solid and well put-together as always.  If you look closely
you'll see places where they've cut corners but overall the machine looks pretty good.

It's on the inside that things have gone to hell.  Where there used to be massive bearings there
are now bushings, and not some thick bronze bushings that would probably be ok but these flimsy
thin plastic things (I haven't seen what the bushings look like in the gearcase).  And lately they've
even gotten rid of some of the bushings so there are no longer any replaceable bearing surfaces
in those places.

Things work fine at the beginning, it's what happens down the road that is questionable.
Problem is bean counters don't usually look very far in that direction.  I mean, where's the
profit if the machine lasts for twenty or thirty years ?

Paul
borat


Joined: Nov 10, 2007
Points: 2692

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #20   Dec 7, 2008 3:25 pm
 I mean, where's the profit if the machine lasts for twenty or thirty years ?

The profit in the above is garnering respect of the consumer and capturing market share for having the best product of that type out there.   Ariens did that.  They established their huge market share on the phenomenal reputation of their machines.  Snapper/Simplicity and Toro did the same but didn't quite market their products as successfully as Ariens.  Their machines have always been as good as Ariens but sales never achieved the market share that they truly deserved.   Toro is not as far off the mark as Simplicity/Snapper is when it comes to marketing their snow throwers.  Toro also have chosen to down grade their machines while still advertising their legendary reputation for durability.  I don't think Toro has slid as much as Ariens, but the writing's pretty much on the wall when you see their products in big box stores.  Seeing a particular model selling for nearly half it's original (pre-big box store) price  is usually a tell tale sign that something's been compromised.   I figure it's only a matter of time before all of the domestic snow thrower manufacturers follow suit.  Hopefully not, but I think it's inevitable.  Now that Simplicity/Snapper is subsidiary of Briggs & Stratten, I suspect their "modernization" will happen sooner than later.  I predict that Honda will be the last to fall.  Japanese manufacturing pride and culture will resist  compromising the quality of their products despite the possibility for loss of sales.   They had to fight too hard and long to establish their reputation for reliability and are keenly aware of it's true significance.  They are also aware that they can charge a premium for their machines and there will always be a niche market for long lasting low maintenance snow throwers.     

End of sermon.    

This message was modified Dec 7, 2008 by borat
pvrp


Joined: Nov 14, 2008
Points: 151

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #21   Dec 7, 2008 5:55 pm

I wrote :

>  I mean, where's the profit if the machine lasts for twenty or thirty years ?

to which borat replies :
The profit in the above is garnering respect of the consumer and capturing market share for having the best
product of that type out there.   Ariens did that.  They established their huge market share on the phenomenal
reputation of their machines.

Ah, the good old days...  Judging from the history of the Ariens company, found at :

      http://www.ariens.com/corporate/aboutus/history.aspx

we probably have Dan Ariens to blame (I bet he went to business school, and if
not his VPs certainly did  :-)

The problem as I see it is that the business world has replaced the idea that a good
product is something that is well made and preforms well, with the idea that a good
product is something that can generate a maximum of profit - at the expense of quality
and performance if necessary.  A good product is something that sells, not necessarily
something that works and lasts.

Unfortunately for us they don't teach mechanics in business school.

I can't see this philosophy lasting forever. I wonder when the decision was made to
sacrifice quality for quantity.  It would be interesting to know if there could have been
a sustainable point on the chart that was reached by maintaining quality, lowering
production and increasing prices instead of lowering quality, increasing production
and lowering prices.  I suppose there'd be a problem if it turned out that they would
have had to charge $10,000 for a Pro model.  I was expecting to pay close to $3000
for my 9526 (I paid something like $2400 for my 1024 back in 1999) and was surprised
when I found out the price, thinking it was a pretty good deal.  Until I found out why.

Here's an article that sort of describes what happened to Ariens :

     http://www.mrotoday.com/mro/archives/Cover%20stories/AriensON03.htm

Paul

This message was modified Dec 7, 2008 by pvrp
goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #22   Dec 9, 2008 2:20 pm
Thanks for the article Paul.

Cheers
Goofie Newfie
coasteray


El Toro! 1028 LXE
Tecumseh 358cc
10hp


Location: NE Washington State
Joined: Mar 3, 2008
Points: 142

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #23   Dec 14, 2008 1:11 am
While on another snow blower and lawn mower forum that many of you probably know of, I posted a long list of questions about Ariens snow blowers in regard to gear boxes, as well as  bearings and bushings.  Check out the good information in the thread.
This message was modified Dec 14, 2008 by coasteray


  El Toro! 1028 LXE - Tecumseh 358cc 10hp   Let it snow! Let it snow! Let it snow!
goofienewfie


Ariens 1130DLE

Joined: Oct 25, 2007
Points: 107

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #24   Dec 15, 2008 1:21 am
Yeah, I noticed that post yesterday morning and was to tired to reply. That information is great and would be nice if all manufactures listed the changes in that manner. Guessing its inside knowledge that they don't want other manufactures to know, but its sure nice to see change reasoning.

Yesterday morning I was debating on copying and pasting it here for others to see. May be better then redirecting people. Just a thought.

Cheers
Goofie Newfie
coasteray


El Toro! 1028 LXE
Tecumseh 358cc
10hp


Location: NE Washington State
Joined: Mar 3, 2008
Points: 142

Re: My complaints about my Ariens Snowblower /Thrower
Reply #25   Dec 16, 2008 4:32 am
goofienewfie wrote:
Yeah, I noticed that post yesterday morning and was to tired to reply. That information is great and would be nice if all manufactures listed the changes in that manner. Guessing its inside knowledge that they don't want other manufactures to know, but its sure nice to see change reasoning.

Yesterday morning I was debating on copying and pasting it here for others to see. May be better then redirecting people. Just a thought.

Yeah, I thought of doing something like that, but I feel weird involving another forum with this one.  Is it even legal?  I really hope others will check it out.  There are only a couple or three forums dealing with snow blowers ( and other OPE), so I hope others will check out the thread on the other forum that says its the "Best" (hint).  I'm sure a lot of members here know about the various forums.  The thread is titled regarding gear boxes. 

  El Toro! 1028 LXE - Tecumseh 358cc 10hp   Let it snow! Let it snow! Let it snow!
Replies: 1 - 25 of 25View as Outline
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Guide   •   Discussions  Reviews  
AbbysGuide.com   About Us   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Contact Us
Copyright 1998-2024 AbbysGuide.com. All rights reserved.